← back to the document

What changed

Graham Kemish v The Information Commissioner · редакция 1 → 2 · зафиксировано 2026-10-22 02:53 · +5 −5 lines

1.
(c)
SCC no-show at hearings where PCN content omissions, and legitimate appellant challenges, were upheld.
SCC no-show at hearings where PCN content omissions, and legitimate appellant challenges, were upheld”.
10.
(b)
Inadequately sighted signage failing to give drivers time to understand and react.
Inadequately sighted signage failing to give drivers time to understand and react”.
14.
3.
Cases (2021-2024) where PCNs cited “bus lane” contraventions but used Code 34.
Cases (2021-2024) where PCNs cited “bus lane” contraventions but used Code 34”.
15.
- Appeals won due to confusion over time restrictions.
- Cancellation rates for vulnerable groups (e.g. neurodivergent drivers).
- Cancellation rates for vulnerable groups (e.g. neurodivergent drivers)”.
23.
47.
The Commissioner filed his response on 20 May 2026, in which he stood by the Decision Notice. In relation to the requests that fell under the FOIA, the Commissioner maintained that, in all of the circumstances of this case, the requests were vexatious. In relation to the requests that fell under the EIR, the Commissioner maintained that, in all of the circumstances of this case, the requests were manifestly unreasonable. In relation to the requests falling under the EIR, the Commissioner also concluded that the maintenance of the exception in rule 112 outweighed the public interest in disclosure of the withheld information.
The Commissioner filed his response on 20 May 2026, in which he stood by the Decision Notice. In relation to the requests that fell under the FOIA, the Commissioner maintained that, in all of the circumstances of this case, the requests were vexatious. In relation to the requests that fell under the EIR, the Commissioner maintained that, in all of the circumstances of this case, the requests were manifestly unreasonable. In relation to the requests falling under the EIR, the Commissioner also concluded that the maintenance of the exception in regulation 12(4)(b) outweighed the public interest in disclosure of the withheld information.
Legal Framework
The Tribunal dismisses the appeal for the reasons given above.