← back to the document

What changed

Ben Lotz v The Information Commissioner & Anor · редакция 1 → 2 · зафиксировано 2026-09-30 01:31 · +25 −19 lines

CORRECTED REASONS
Corrected under rule 40 of The Tribunal Procedure (First Tier Tribunal) (General Regulatory Chambers) Rules 2009
Introduction
“
…I need an email address for a staff contact in the JSA (Jobseeker’s Allowance) Team, the ESA (Employment and Support Allowance) Team, and the UC (Universal Credit) Team. Only one per team per Jobcentre; but for every Jobcentre in London.
Please provide the most appropriate one for claimants to contact that provides the appropriate team.
The most appropriate could, for example, be the most senior public-facing contact in that team.
In terms of practicality, I suggest you contact the Manager of each Jobcentre to provide these contacts and email addresses.
My request also implies a list of Jobcentres in London, so that it is clear for claimants who to contact in which Jobcentre.
…I need an email address for (a staff contact in) the JSA (JobseekersAllowance) Team, the ESA (EmploymentSupportAllowance) Team, the UC (UniversalCredit) Team.
But I only need 1 per each of these teams per Jobcentre; but for every JobCentre in London. Please provide the most appropriate one for claimants to contact that team.
The most appropriate could e.g. be the most senior public-facing contact in that team.
In terms of practicality, I suggest you contact the Manager of each JobCentre to provide these contacts + email-addresses.
My request implies also a list of JobCentres in London, so that it is clear for claimants who to contact in which Jobcentre.
Example:
8.
The Commissioner said that determining what information was held involved making a judgement on whether each Jobcentre has an associated set out three emails that can publicly be announced as ‘appropriate’ for all of the specific benefit claimants of that Jobcentre to use, potentially resulting in hundreds or thousands of emails being sent outside of DWP’s set processes.
The Commissioner said that determining what information was held involved making a judgement on whether each Jobcentre has an associated set of three emails that can publicly be announced as ‘appropriate’ for all of the specific benefit claimants of that Jobcentre to use, potentially resulting in hundreds or thousands of emails being sent outside of DWP’s set processes.
9.
11.1.
The Commissioner was wrong to conclude that the estimate was reasonable and that the Trust was entitled to rely on
The Commissioner was wrong to conclude that the estimate was reasonable and that the DWP was entitled to rely on
section 12(1)
.
23.
He said that he availability of this email address, along with the lack of information on the Digital Directorate, was relevant to the duty to provide advice and assistance.
He said that the availability of this email address, along with the lack of information on the Digital Directorate, was relevant to the duty to provide advice and assistance.
24.
41.
The DWP submitted that due to the fact that it is not mandatory for sites to have external e-mail addresses, the fact that these could possibly be produced at any period in time by any colleague, and the fact that the e-mail address may not have been named after its site name, searching through the GAL using the filters available.
The DWP submitted that due to the fact that it is not mandatory for sites to have external e-mail addresses, the fact that these could possibly be produced at any period in time by any colleague, and the fact that the e-mail address may not have been named after its site name, searching through the GAL using the filters available would be insufficient.
42.
45.
The DWP submitted that additionally the searches and filters would be in respect of one Jobcentre’s inbox but the requestor had asked for a JSA, EA and UC email inboxes for each Jobcentre in London for claimants to contact.
The DWP submitted that additionally the searches and filters would be in respect of one Jobcentre’s inbox but the requestor had asked for a JSA, ESA and UC email inbox for each Jobcentre in London for claimants to contact.
46.
47.
In relation to the emails addresses available for communication between Jobcentres and for central teams to contact individual Jobcentres, the DWP submitted that colleagues have access to the GAL, Microsoft Teams and the intranet which provide a list of colleague contacts for sites, broken down by Directorates to help narrow searches and find particular job roles. The DWP said that there are also internal only email address not for the purpose of the requestor’s request. The DWP said that each Jobcentre had a Customer Service Leader and the contact details of the appropriate person could be found internally by colleagues. The DWP said that Jobcentres are also structured within Areas, Groups and Districts so that individuals within those areas will be acquainted with sites within those locations.
In relation to the email addresses available for communication between Jobcentres and for central teams to contact individual Jobcentres, the DWP submitted that colleagues have access to the GAL, Microsoft Teams and the intranet which provide a list of colleague contacts for sites, broken down by Directorates to help narrow searches and find particular job roles. The DWP said that there are also internal only email address not for the purpose of the requestor’s request. The DWP said that each Jobcentre had a Customer Service Leader and the contact details of the appropriate person could be found internally by colleagues. The DWP said that Jobcentres are also structured within Areas, Groups and Districts so that individuals within those areas will be acquainted with sites within those locations.
48.
55.
Mr Lotz asked the tribunal to consider with the overall delay caused by DWP’s refusal to allow their submission to be shared and to advise the Commissioner on how to interpret sections 19 and 20 and on external legal duties.
Mr Lotz asked the tribunal to consider the overall delay caused by DWP’s refusal to allow their submission to be shared and to advise the Commissioner on how to interpret sections 19 and 20 and on external legal duties.
56.
-
that is the ‘most appropriate’ email address for claimants to contact that ‘provides the appropriate team’
that is the ‘most appropriate’ email address for claimants to contact that team
73.
Signed Sophie Buckley
Date:
18 June 2026
Date: 18 June 2026
Date of corrected decision:
28 September 2026
Judge of the First-tier Tribunal