Pulse · Documents · United Kingdom · Courts of England and Wales

Peter Morgan v The Information Commissioner

court decision 2026-10-13 5 778 characters Personal data
Download On the source site Original file
Current version. Last change recorded on 2026-10-14.

1.The Information Commissioner (“the Commissioner”) made an application in the Response the dated 12 June 2026 for the appeal to be struck out under rule 8(3)(c) of the Rules. Case Management Directions dated 30 July 2026 directed the Appellant to file and serve written submissions within 7 days if he wished to oppose the application of the Commissioner to strike out the appeal. It was directed that the Appellant explain why he contended that the appeal has a reasonable prospect of success. In particular, the Appellant was directed to identify the respects in which he contended that the Commissioner was wrong to argue that the Notice of Appeal disclosed no arguable challenge to the Commissioner’s decision Notice of 23 April 2026 (“the Decision Notice”).

2.The Appellant has not filed any written submissions. I have made the decision on the basis of the evidence available.

3.The appeal against the Decision Notice is brought by the Appellant under section 57 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (“FOIA”) as modified by regulation 18 of the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 (“EIR”).

4.The Commissioner submits that the appeal should be struck out on the grounds that the Appellant failed to set out in the grounds of appeal why the Decision Notice is not in accordance with the law or that the Commissioner ought to have exercised his discretion differently.

5.The Appellant was concerned about the storage of building materials during construction work on a neighbouring property. He wrote to Hertfordshire County Council (“the Council”) on 29 April 2025. In the request he sought information concerning licences for the storage of building materials on a public highway, public liability insurance, and any enforcement action taken in relation to alleged breaches arising from a neighbouring construction project.

6.The Council refused to confirm or deny whether it held information within the scope of the request, relying on regulation 13(5A) EIR. The Appellant requested an internal review on 18 July 2025 and the Council responded on 28 July 2026 upholding its original decision.

7.The Appellant complained to the Commissioner on 2 September 2026. The Commissioner concluded that the Council was entitled to rely on regulation 13(5A) EIR and that the Council had breached regulation 5(2) EIR in not providing a response to the request within 20 working days.

8.I have considered carefully the Appellant’s grounds of appeal which are essentially that there are date errors within the Decision Notice, that information requested was not disclosed, and that skip licences had previously been supplied to him. The Appellant further states that he seeks justice and prosecutions arising from the construction works.

9.The Commissioner resists this appeal and submits that the appeal has no reasonable prospects of success on the basis of a) the clear reasoning set out in his Decision Notice for the application of the neither confirm nor deny provision and b) the fact that the Appellant has already received information outside of the EIR, such as to render this appeal an abuse of process

10.The Commissioner submits that the Appellant has not identified any error of law concerning his Decision Notice. The Appellant has only referred to what are clearly typographical errors of little substance within the Decision Notice, and a prior disclosure of information for which there is little evidence of the context, and which cannot impact on the separate consideration of whether it would have been in contravention of the first data protection principle to confirm or deny under EIR whether the information requested in this matter is held. Furthermore it seems likely given the disclosure referred to that the previous disclosure may well have been made outside of the EIR. These arguments clearly have no reasonable prospect of success in disturbing the Commissioner’s clear application and consideration of the applicable regulation in the Decision Notice. On this basis alone the Commissioner submits that the Appellant’s grounds have no reasonable prospects of success and should be struck out under Rule 8(3)(c).

11.The Commissioner submits that this appeal should be struck out also on the grounds that the appeal is an abuse of process given that it is academic in light of the Appellant having received some disclosure of information outside of the EIR. It is open to the Appellant to pursue obtaining any further information outside of the EIR, and the Commissioner has not seen any evidence to suggest this has been attempted or exhausted; rather the Appellant has sought to pursue his objectives by way of this appeal but without engaging in the substantive arguments for the neither confirm nor deny position under the EIR.

12.The Commissioner relies on the analysis of Judge Buckley of this First-tier Tribunal in her decision in Edward Williams v Information Commissioner & the University of Southampton EA/2022/0139. In that decision Judge Buckley considered Rule 8(3)(c) to be sufficient to grant the Tribunal the power to dispose of proceedings that are academic.

13.I find that the grounds of appeal do not identify any arguable error of law in the Commissioner's reasoning, nor do they identify any basis upon which the Commissioner exercised his discretion wrongly. The alleged date errors amount, at their highest, to typographical matters which do not affect the substance of the Commissioner's analysis or conclusions. I am not persuaded that any such errors amount to an arguable error of law in the Decision Notice.

14.Pursuant to rule 8(3)(c) of the Rules I strike out the appeal on the grounds that there is no reasonable prospect of the Appellant’s case, or part of it, succeeding.