← к документу

Что изменилось

Advanced Drainage Systems Inc. -v- Microstrain Limited [Trading As CUBICM3) · редакция 1 → 2 · зафиксировано 2026-11-05 02:18 · +593 −221 строк

COMMERCIAL COURT
## COMMERCIAL COURT
[2026] IEHC 577
RECORD NUMBER 2024/7415
THE HIGH COURT
## RECORD NUMBER 2024/7415
## THE HIGH COURT
BETWEEN
ADVANCED DRAINAGE SYSTEMS INC
## ADVANCED DRAINAGE SYSTEMS INC
PLAINTIFF
AND
MICROSTRAIN LIMITED TRADING AS CUBICM3
## MICROSTRAIN LIMITED TRADING AS CUBICM3
DEFENDANT
JUDGMENT of Mr. Justice Twomey delivered on the 15th day of October, 2026
## JUDGMENT of Mr. Justice Twomey delivered on the 15th day of October, 2026
INTRODUCTION
This is a discovery application in a dispute regarding stormwater pipes (sometimes called chambers or tanks) between the plaintiff (“ADS”) which sells pipes known as StormTech, and the defendant (“Cubic”) which supplies pipes known as RainSafe. The pipes are supplied so as to provide a stormwater attenuation solution on building and infrastructure projects, i.e. to ensure that the rainwater is safely diverted and dealt with in storm conditions.
ADS alleges that Cubic has breached ADS’s copyright in the StormTech brand. In particular, ADS claims that Cubic has breached this copyright in the manner in which Cubic’s RainSafe pipes are sub-corrugated. ADS also claims that Cubic has infringed ADS’s copyright in installation guides and brochures which ADS has for its StormTech pipes.
ADS further alleges that Cubic is passing-off pipes which Cubic supplies to customers as those of ADS, and that Cubic has infringed ADS’s EU trademark ‘STORMTECH’ by virtue of Cubic’s registration of a domain name and business name, which ADS claims infringed this trademark.
The background to the dispute is that between 2003 and 2024, Cubic was a distributor of ADS’s StormTech pipes, since Cubic used these pipes as part of Cubic’s rainwater attenuation systems, which it supplied to its customers. However, this distribution arrangement came to an end in 2024 and Cubic has since gone into competition with ADS, by manufacturing its own pipes, which it markets under the RainSafe brand.
Cubic denies that its pipes (the RT-720 and RT-1140 models) were copied from ADS’s pipes (the MC-3500 and the DC-780 models). Cubic claims its pipes are superior to ADS’s pipes and it points to the fact that it has obtained certification from a French certification organisation for its pipes.
The customer or end user usually comes into possession of the pipes, whether StormTech’s or RainSafe’s, when it is provided with a service for the design and installation of a stormwater pipes on building and infrastructure projects. This is the service that Cubic supplies in the Irish market, now with RainSafe pipes, and which it previously supplied, using StormTech pipes.
In its defence, Cubic claims that ADS is not involved in the provision of this type of service, but this is denied by ADS. In particular, Cubic claims that ADS simply supplies the pipes, rather than a service. Cubic says that Resolute, a third party, now does what Cubic had done for 20 years, namely Resolute supplies the stormwater attenuation service in Ireland using StormTech’s pipes. In this regard, in related proceedings, instituted by Cubic against ADS, Cubic alleges that ADS damaged Cubic’s commercial interests by conspiring with third parties to set up Resolute to supply the StormTech pipes to the Irish market and put Cubic out of business. These claims are all denied by ADS.
The discovery and inspection motions
There are three motions before the Court, one in which ADS seeks discovery from Cubic, another in which ADS seeks an order for inspection of some samples of Cubic’s RainSafe pipes, and a third in which Cubic seeks discovery from ADS.
Before considering these motions it is relevant to note the following evidence, which was provided to the Court by ADS, of the alleged breach of its intellectual property rights by Cubic:
photographs indicating an alleged similarity in appearance between ADS’s StormTech pipes and Cubic’s RainSafe pipes and in particular regarding Cubic’s use of corrugation.
Cubic’s response to copyright infringement claims by ADS regarding the contents of Cubic’s brochures and the use of images on Cubic’s website, which it is alleged are from ADS’s brochure and installation guide. In this response, Cubic accepted that there had been a ‘use of ADS’ materials’ and as a result Cubic altered the offending materials (marketing and installation brochures), however Cubic maintained that it had a right to display images of previous installations on its website, and that there was a practice between the two parties in which each used the others imagery.
Documentation was provided which indicates that ADS owns an EU trademark for ‘STORMTECH’, and which indicated that the domain name ‘stormtech.ie’ was either registered or renewed in August 2023 by Cubic, and it was not disputed by Cubic that the domain name was subsequently transferred to ADS in October 2025, only after ADS had repeatedly written to Cubic.
Mr Justin Elliott, managing director of Cubic, in his affidavit of 10 June 2026, accepts that requests for proposals, received by Cubic, from prospective buyers of rain attenuation systems, may identify StormTech products, but that Cubic may propose alternative products. ADS alleges that acceptance, in this affidavit, by Cubic, supports an inference that StormTech specifications or materials were used to tender for projects in which RainSafe products were ultimately substituted or supplied, a practice ADS describes as ‘bait and switch’.
Ms. Colette Brady, solicitor for ADS, in her affidavit of 15 January 2025, at para. 48, referred to correspondence concerning Cubic’s registration and use of StormTech as a business name. She averred that this registration and use occurred without ADS’s knowledge or consent and it forms part of ADS’s allegations of infringement of its STORMTECH trade mark.
This evidence of an alleged breach of intellectual property rights is relevant because it is clear from the decision in Keating v RTE and the Commissioner of An Garda Siochana [2013] 2 I.L.R.M. 145, at para. 63, that before discovery will be ordered, there must be ‘some information on which the plea is based’. In this regard, it appears to this Court that the foregoing amounts to information upon which are based the pleas that Cubic (a distributor of ADS’s StormmTech pipes for over 20 years, but now supplying its own branded pipes, RainSafe) breached ADS’s intellectual property rights.
In this case, some of the documentation, which is sought by ADS from Cubic, and by Cubic from ADS, in the discovery applications, is alleged by ADS and by Cubic, respectively, to be confidential. It is clear from Tobin v Minister for Defence [2020] I.R. 211 at para. 44, per Clarke C.J., that disclosure of confidential information must be ‘truly necessary to the resolution of the proceedings’ before it will be ordered by a court.
To the extent that this Court determines that information, which is alleged to be confidential, should be discovered under any of the following categories, it does so on the basis that it is truly necessary for the resolution of the proceedings. However, it is crucial to bear in mind that this information will still be subject to a form of confidentiality agreement/confidentiality ring (and efforts have been made to agree same between the parties), in order to ensure that this information is used for the purposes of this litigation and for no other purpose. The same also applies to information, which is alleged to be confidential, which is garnered from the inspection of samples of Cubic’s RainSafe pipes, the subject of the third motion.
ADS’S APPLICATION FOR DISCOVERY FROM CUBIC
The first category of discovery that ADS seeks from Cubic is as follows:
Category One
1. This is a discovery application in a dispute regarding stormwater pipes (sometimes called chambers or tanks) between the plaintiff (“ADS”) which sells pipes known as StormTech, and the defendant (“Cubic”) which supplies pipes known as RainSafe. The pipes are supplied so as to provide a stormwater attenuation solution on building and infrastructure projects, i.e. to ensure that the rainwater is safely diverted and dealt with in storm conditions.
2. ADS alleges that Cubic has breached ADS’s copyright in the StormTech brand. In particular, ADS claims that Cubic has breached this copyright in the manner in which
Cubic’s RainSafe pipes are sub-corrugated. ADS also claims that Cubic has infringed
ADS’s copyright in installation guides and brochures which ADS has for its StormTech pipes.
3. ADS further alleges that Cubic is passing-off pipes which Cubic supplies to customers as those of ADS, and that Cubic has infringed ADS’s EU trademark ‘STORMTECH’ by virtue of Cubic’s registration of a domain name and business name, which ADS claims infringed this trademark.
4. The background to the dispute is that between 2003 and 2024, Cubic was a distributor of
ADS’s StormTech pipes, since Cubic used these pipes as part of Cubic’s rainwater attenuation systems, which it supplied to its customers. However, this distribution arrangement came to an end in 20241 and Cubic has since gone into competition with ADS, by manufacturing its own pipes, which it markets under the RainSafe brand.
5. Cubic denies that its pipes (the RT-720 and RT-1140 models) were copied from ADS’s pipes (the MC-3500 and the DC-780 models). Cubic claims its pipes are superior to ADS’s pipes and it points to the fact that it has obtained certification from a French certification organisation for its pipes.
6. The customer or end user usually comes into possession of the pipes, whether StormTech’s or RainSafe’s, when it is provided with a service for the design and installation of a
1 Transcript, Day 1, pg. 9, line 28.
stormwater pipes on building and infrastructure projects. This is the service that Cubic supplies in the Irish market, now with RainSafe pipes, and which it previously supplied, using StormTech pipes.
7. In its defence, Cubic claims that ADS is not involved in the provision of this type of service, but this is denied by ADS. In particular, Cubic claims that ADS simply supplies the pipes, rather than a service. Cubic says that Resolute, a third party, now does what Cubic had done for 20 years, namely Resolute supplies the stormwater attenuation service in Ireland using
StormTech’s pipes. In this regard, in related proceedings, instituted by Cubic against ADS,
Cubic alleges that ADS damaged Cubic’s commercial interests by conspiring with third parties to set up Resolute to supply the StormTech pipes to the Irish market and put Cubic out of business. These claims are all denied by ADS.
## The discovery and inspection motions
8. There are three motions before the Court, one in which ADS seeks discovery from Cubic, another in which ADS seeks an order for inspection of some samples of Cubic’s RainSafe pipes, and a third in which Cubic seeks discovery from ADS.
9. Before considering these motions it is relevant to note the following evidence, which was provided to the Court by ADS, of the alleged breach of its intellectual property rights by
Cubic:
• photographs indicating an alleged similarity in appearance between ADS’s StormTech pipes and Cubic’s RainSafe pipes and in particular regarding Cubic’s use of corrugation.
• Cubic’s response to copyright infringement claims by ADS regarding the contents of
Cubic’s brochures and the use of images on Cubic’s website, which it is alleged are from ADS’s brochure and installation guide. In this response, Cubic accepted that there had been a ‘use of ADS’ materials’2 and as a result Cubic altered the offending materials (marketing and installation brochures), however Cubic maintained that it had a right to display images of previous installations on its website, and that there was a practice between the two parties in which each used the others imagery.
• Documentation was provided which indicates that ADS owns an EU trademark for
‘STORMTECH’,3 and which indicated that the domain name ‘stormtech.ie’4 was either registered or renewed in August 2023 by Cubic, and it was not disputed by Cubic that the domain name was subsequently transferred to ADS in October 2025, only after ADS had repeatedly written to Cubic.
• Mr Justin Elliott, managing director of Cubic, in his affidavit of 10 June 2026, accepts that requests for proposals, received by Cubic, from prospective buyers of rain attenuation systems, may identify StormTech products, but that Cubic may propose alternative products. ADS alleges that acceptance, in this affidavit, by Cubic, supports an inference that StormTech specifications or materials were used to tender for projects in which RainSafe products were ultimately substituted or supplied, a practice ADS describes as ‘bait and switch’.
• Ms. Colette Brady, solicitor for ADS, in her affidavit of 15 January 2025, at para. 48, referred to correspondence concerning Cubic’s registration and use of StormTech as a business name. She averred that this registration and use occurred without ADS’s knowledge or consent and it forms part of ADS’s allegations of infringement of its
STORMTECH trade mark.
10. This evidence of an alleged breach of intellectual property rights is relevant because it is clear from the decision in Keating v RTE and the Commissioner of An Garda Siochana
2 Book of Pleadings, Affidavit of Mr. Justin Elliott, managing director of Cubic, dated 4 February 2025, para. 46. 3 Statement of Claim, para. 9. 4 Statement of Claim, para. 12.
[2013] 2 I.L.R.M. 145, at para. 63, that before discovery will be ordered, there must be
‘some information on which the plea is based’. In this regard, it appears to this Court that the foregoing amounts to information upon which are based the pleas that Cubic (a distributor of ADS’s StormmTech pipes for over 20 years, but now supplying its own branded pipes, RainSafe) breached ADS’s intellectual property rights.
11. In this case, some of the documentation, which is sought by ADS from Cubic, and by Cubic from ADS, in the discovery applications, is alleged by ADS and by Cubic, respectively, to be confidential. It is clear from Tobin v Minister for Defence [2020] I.R. 211 at para. 44, per Clarke C.J., that disclosure of confidential information must be ‘truly necessary to the resolution of the proceedings’ before it will be ordered by a court.
12. To the extent that this Court determines that information, which is alleged to be confidential, should be discovered under any of the following categories, it does so on the basis that it is truly necessary for the resolution of the proceedings. However, it is crucial to bear in mind that this information will still be subject to a form of confidentiality agreement/confidentiality ring (and efforts have been made to agree same between the parties), in order to ensure that this information is used for the purposes of this litigation and for no other purpose. The same also applies to information, which is alleged to be confidential, which is garnered from the inspection of samples of Cubic’s RainSafe pipes, the subject of the third motion.
## ADS’S APPLICATION FOR DISCOVERY FROM CUBIC
13. The first category of discovery that ADS seeks from Cubic is as follows:
## Category One
‘All documents which evidence, concern or refer to the design, development, prototype manufacture and approval process that led to the Rainsafe Products and the appearance thereof (including but not limited to all documents which concern or refer to designs consulted, considered, modified or abandoned, and the basis for the same, during the course of that process, all agreements entered into with personnel involved in the design, development and approval process, and all attempts to enter into agreements with third parties relating to the design, development, and approval process).’
Cubic has offered the following category of discovery in response, subject, it seems, to an appropriate confidentiality constraint being agreed:
‘Documents sufficient to evidence the design, development and prototype manufacture that led to the RainSafe Products and the appearance thereof (including documents which refer to designs consulted, considered or modified and the basis for the same, during the course of that process) and to include all design briefs or instructions given to any person involved in the design and development which refer to or relate to ADS’ StormTech Products.’
Since ADS claims, and Cubic denies, that Cubic copied ADS’s products, the category, as proposed by ADS, is plainly relevant and it seems to this Court to be truly necessary to be disclosed, since it deals with the design of the allegedly offending product.
This Court will therefore order the category proposed by ADS, but removing the words ‘or abandoned, and the basis for same’, since this is a reference to designs which were abandoned, and so of limited, if any, relevance, in this Court’s view. Similarly, this Court would remove the words ‘and all attempts to enter into agreements with third parties relating to the design, development, and approval process’, since this is also of limited relevance, in this Court’s view.
It seems clear that some of the discovered material will be commercially sensitive/confidential and so the confidentiality arrangements, to be agreed between the parties, can deal with this issue.
Category 4
ADS seeks from Cubic:
‘All documents which evidence, concern or refer to reports or complaints by parties other than ADS regarding the RainSafe Products, including but not limited to any instances of confusion or association as between the RainSafe Products and StormTech Products.’
Cubic has offered the following category of discovery in response:
‘All documents which evidence, concern or refer to reports or complaints by non-parties received by CubicM3 relating to or evidencing any instances of confusion or association as between the RainSafe Products and StormTech Products.’
Since one is dealing with a passing off claim, clearly complaints from customers that they have been misled into believing that they were buying StormTech pipes, rather than RainSafe pipes, are relevant.
However, as Cubic is in competition with ADS, Cubic makes the valid point that if it were to disclose to ADS all customer complaints regarding its products, this would be commercially sensitive and damaging information to have to disclose to a competitor. Hence, Cubic claims that this category should be limited to complaints evidencing confusion between RainSafe and StormTech products, rather than complaints about RainSafe products generally.
This Court sees merit in this argument, and it believes that it should seek to protect Cubic’s commercially sensitive information, as this information is not required for the establishment of the alleged wrong. Hence, this Court would order the Category, in the format offered by Cubic.
There does not appear to be any claim of confidentiality regarding this material, but to the extent that there is a claim a confidentiality in this category (or, indeed, in any of the categories by either party), this can be dealt with by the terms of the confidentiality arrangement to be agreed by the parties.
Category 5
ADS seeks from Cubic:
‘All documents evidencing, concerning and/or recording any and/or all contracts and/or projects which were tendered using the StormTech Products, the Sub Corrugation Products, and/or the StormTech Marketing and Instructional Materials, but which were ultimately supplied with the RainSafe Products.’
Cubic claims that this category is not relevant because ADS did not plead that Cubic’s ‘tendering’ amounted to an infringement of ADS’s rights. This Court does not accept Cubic’s point because there is express reference at para. 12 of the Statement of Claim to the fact that Cubic has ‘offered and exposed for sale’ its RainSafe pipes in breach of ADS’s rights. In this Court’s view this is sufficient to cover a claim regarding tendering, which is a form of offering for sale.
As regards the means of satisfying this category, it has been agreed in principle between the parties that Cubic would satisfy this category by preparing a spreadsheet enumerating:
‘those contracts and/or projects which were tendered using the StormTech Products, the Sub Corrugation Products, and/or the StormTech Marketing and Instructional Material but which were ultimately supplied with the RainSafe Products’
along with the underlying documents in respect of those projects.
Cubic has suggested that it provide five such projects tendered during the period August 2024 to 2025, but ADS believes that this is too restrictive. ADS points out that one does not know what proportion, of all the projects tendered by Cubic, would be represented by five projects.
There is merit to ADS’s arguments, in this Court’s view. Accordingly, this Court will amend this response to the category by requiring Cubic to provide 10% of the projects, or 10 of the projects, whichever is the larger number, without any time limit (which in any case is unlikely to be more than 4 years, since Cubic has only been in competition with ADS for less than 4 years.)
Category 6
ADS seeks from Cubic:
‘A copy of each distinct document comprising or containing a publication, advertisement or marketing material, and/or any potential or actual offer, supply, sale or use of the RainSafe Products, to include:-
a copy of each distinct document distributed by the Defendant at conferences, exhibitions or meetings;
content uploaded to and shown on the Defendant’s website;
content uploaded to and shown on the Defendant’s website www.rainsafe.eu;
a copy of each distinct document sent to external persons or entities in respect of the RainSafe Products;
a copy of each distinct document used for promotional or sales purposes on site visits or other activities in the State by any representative of the Defendant engaged in the sale or promotion of the RainSafe Products;
representative samples of inquires received from persons or entities regarding the supply of the RainSafe Products;
final version supply contracts, installation contracts, order forms, or invoices regarding the supply of the Rainsafe Products; and
any documentation evidencing the RainSafe Products which have been supplied, installed, maintained or modified in the State and the date of supply, installation, maintenance or modification in question.
Cubic has offered the following category of discovery in response:
‘A copy of each individual document comprising a publication, advertisement or piece of marketing material in respect of the RainSafe Products, and a copy of each standard form offer to supply, sell or use of the RainSafe Products, to include samples of documents (subject to appropriate reduction):-
a) distributed at conferences, exhibitions or meetings;
14. Cubic has offered the following category of discovery in response, subject, it seems, to an appropriate confidentiality constraint being agreed:
‘Documents sufficient to evidence the design, development and prototype manufacture that led to the RainSafe Products and the appearance thereof (including documents which refer to designs consulted, considered or modified and the basis for the same, during the course of that process) and to include all design briefs or instructions given to any person involved in the design and development which refer to or relate to ADS’
StormTech Products.’
15. Since ADS claims, and Cubic denies, that Cubic copied ADS’s products, the category, as proposed by ADS, is plainly relevant and it seems to this Court to be truly necessary to be disclosed, since it deals with the design of the allegedly offending product.
16. This Court will therefore order the category proposed by ADS, but removing the words ‘or abandoned, and the basis for same’, since this is a reference to designs which were abandoned, and so of limited, if any, relevance, in this Court’s view. Similarly, this Court would remove the words ‘and all attempts to enter into agreements with third parties relating to the design, development, and approval process’, since this is also of limited relevance, in this Court’s view.
17. It seems clear that some of the discovered material will be commercially sensitive/confidential and so the confidentiality arrangements, to be agreed between the parties, can deal with this issue.
## Category 4
18. ADS seeks from Cubic:
‘All documents which evidence, concern or refer to reports or complaints by parties other than ADS regarding the RainSafe Products, including but not limited to any instances of confusion or association as between the RainSafe Products and StormTech
Products.’
19. Cubic has offered the following category of discovery in response:
‘All documents which evidence, concern or refer to reports or complaints by nonparties received by CubicM3 relating to or evidencing any instances of confusion or association as between the RainSafe Products and StormTech Products.’
20. Since one is dealing with a passing off claim, clearly complaints from customers that they have been misled into believing that they were buying StormTech pipes, rather than
RainSafe pipes, are relevant.
21. However, as Cubic is in competition with ADS, Cubic makes the valid point that if it were to disclose to ADS all customer complaints regarding its products, this would be commercially sensitive and damaging information to have to disclose to a competitor.
Hence, Cubic claims that this category should be limited to complaints evidencing confusion between RainSafe and StormTech products, rather than complaints about
RainSafe products generally.
22. This Court sees merit in this argument, and it believes that it should seek to protect Cubic’s commercially sensitive information, as this information is not required for the establishment of the alleged wrong. Hence, this Court would order the Category, in the format offered by Cubic.
23. There does not appear to be any claim of confidentiality regarding this material, but to the extent that there is a claim a confidentiality in this category (or, indeed, in any of the categories by either party), this can be dealt with by the terms of the confidentiality arrangement to be agreed by the parties.
## Category 5
24. ADS seeks from Cubic:
‘All documents evidencing, concerning and/or recording any and/or all contracts and/or projects which were tendered using the StormTech Products, the Sub
Corrugation Products, and/or the StormTech Marketing and Instructional Materials, but which were ultimately supplied with the RainSafe Products.’
25. Cubic claims that this category is not relevant because ADS did not plead that Cubic’s
‘tendering’ amounted to an infringement of ADS’s rights. This Court does not accept
Cubic’s point because there is express reference at para. 12 of the Statement of Claim to the fact that Cubic has ‘offered and exposed for sale’ its RainSafe pipes in breach of ADS’s rights. In this Court’s view this is sufficient to cover a claim regarding tendering, which is a form of offering for sale.
26. As regards the means of satisfying this category, it has been agreed in principle between the parties that Cubic would satisfy this category by preparing a spreadsheet enumerating:
‘those contracts and/or projects which were tendered using the StormTech Products, the Sub Corrugation Products, and/or the StormTech Marketing and Instructional
Material but which were ultimately supplied with the RainSafe Products’ along with the underlying documents in respect of those projects.
27. Cubic has suggested that it provide five such projects tendered during the period August
2024 to 2025, but ADS believes that this is too restrictive. ADS points out that one does not know what proportion, of all the projects tendered by Cubic, would be represented by five projects.
28. There is merit to ADS’s arguments, in this Court’s view. Accordingly, this Court will amend this response to the category by requiring Cubic to provide 10% of the projects, or
10 of the projects, whichever is the larger number, without any time limit (which in any case is unlikely to be more than 4 years, since Cubic has only been in competition with
ADS for less than 4 years.)
## Category 6
29. ADS seeks from Cubic:
‘A copy of each distinct document comprising or containing a publication, advertisement or marketing material, and/or any potential or actual offer, supply, sale or use of the RainSafe Products, to include:a) a copy of each distinct document distributed by the Defendant at conferences, exhibitions or meetings;
b) content uploaded to and shown on the Defendant’s website;
c) content uploaded to and shown on the Defendant’s website www.rainsafe.eu;
d) a copy of each distinct document sent to external persons or entities in respect of the RainSafe Products;
e) a copy of each distinct document used for promotional or sales purposes on site visits or other activities in the State by any representative of the Defendant engaged in the sale or promotion of the RainSafe Products;
f) representative samples of inquires received from persons or entities regarding the supply of the RainSafe Products;
g) final version supply contracts, installation contracts, order forms, or invoices regarding the supply of the Rainsafe Products; and h) any documentation evidencing the RainSafe Products which have been supplied, installed, maintained or modified in the State and the date of supply, installation, maintenance or modification in question.
30. Cubic has offered the following category of discovery in response:
‘A copy of each individual document comprising a publication, advertisement or piece of marketing material in respect of the RainSafe Products, and a copy of each standard form offer to supply, sell or use of the RainSafe Products, to include samples of documents (subject to appropriate reduction):a) distributed at conferences, exhibitions or meetings;
b) sent to persons or entities upon enquiry in respect of the RainSafe Products;
c) used for promotional or sales purposes on site visits or in the State by any representative of the Defendant engaged in the sale or promotion of the RainSafe Products;
d) being a sample of a proposal in response to an enquiry for provision of stormwater attenuation;
e) being 5(five) samples, redacted other than any clause/s which refer to the RainSafe Products, of supply contracts and installation contracts; and
j)[sic] printouts of webpages controlled by the Defendant and referring to a RainSafe product.’
This Court will order the category sought by ADS but with the removal of (d) (as this sub-category would require potentially a very large volume of documents sent to a third party to be discovered as this relates to any RainSafe products).
Similarly, this Court will remove sub-category (h) (which includes any documentation for supply installation etc of any RainSafe products), which again is potentially a very large volume of documents.
The other sub-categories sought by ADS are, in this Court’s view, sufficiently broad to disclose the marketing material which is the target of this category.
CUBIC’S APPLICATION FOR DISCOVERY FROM ADS
Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following categories:
Category 1A
‘Documents evidencing or referring to the Plaintiff's assertion that it distributes and
supplies the StormTech attenuation systems as a service into the Irish market since
2003, to include but not limited to any design specification and marketing materials for any such service, but excluding (i)any documents relating to any component part that ADS has sold as part of a system designed and supplied by another entity; and (ii) any service supplied by the Defendant or Resolute on the Plaintiff's behalf.’
Category 1B
‘Documents not falling under Category 1A upon which the Plaintiff will rely in the
proceedings to show that the Plaintiff has designed, distributed and supplied the
e) being 5(five) samples, redacted other than any clause/s which refer to the RainSafe
Products, of supply contracts and installation contracts; and j)[sic] printouts of webpages controlled by the Defendant and referring to a RainSafe product.’
31. This Court will order the category sought by ADS but with the removal of (d) (as this subcategory would require potentially a very large volume of documents sent to a third party to be discovered as this relates to any RainSafe products).
32. Similarly, this Court will remove sub-category (h) (which includes any documentation for supply installation etc of any RainSafe products), which again is potentially a very large volume of documents.
33. The other sub-categories sought by ADS are, in this Court’s view, sufficiently broad to disclose the marketing material which is the target of this category.
## CUBIC’S APPLICATION FOR DISCOVERY FROM ADS
34. Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following categories:
## Category 1A
‘Documents evidencing or referring to the Plaintiff's assertion that it distributes and supplies the StormTech attenuation systems as a service into the Irish market since
2003, to include but not limited to any design specification and marketing materials for any such service, but excluding (i)any documents relating to any component part that
ADS has sold as part of a system designed and supplied by another entity; and (ii) any service supplied by the Defendant or Resolute on the Plaintiff's behalf.’
## Category 1B
‘Documents not falling under Category 1A upon which the Plaintiff will rely in the proceedings to show that the Plaintiff has designed, distributed and supplied the
StormTech attenuation systems as a service into the Irish market since 2003.’
The background to this category is that the question of whether or not ADS supplies a service, as distinct from just goods, is an issue in this case. However, it seems to this Court that a search of electronic documents going back nearly a quarter of a century (for every single document making any reference whatsoever to ADS’s provision of the StormTech attenuation systems service) would require a very good reason. In Biogen Inc. v Celltrion Inc. [2018] IEHC 239, at para. 4, where the relevant discovery timeframes which were requested were ‘14 and 22-year periods’, Barrett J. held that such timeframes would require ‘very explicit justification’. This case involves a time-range of even longer than the one considered by Barrett J., namely 24 years. This Court does not believe that there is sufficient justification for such a time frame. Indeed, it is genuinely difficult for this Court to see how Cubic, in suggesting such a broad trawl through documents, could not have seen how unreasonable this is, as a request for discovery. Of course, it is possible that a document could turn up from 24 years ago that is relevant to these proceedings. However, this amounts, in this Court’s opinion, to making discovery the search for perfect truth, which was deprecated by the Supreme Court, without any regard to how reasonable such a request is and to any sense of proportion. As noted by Fennelly J. the ‘public interest in the proper administration of justice is not confined to the relentless search for perfect truth. The just and proper conduct of litigation also encompasses the objectives of expedition and economy.’
Would requesting party regard request as reasonable/proportionate if it was recipient?
In this regard, and as a general point, in this Court’s view, a lot of discovery requests would disappear or be radically amended, if litigants who look for discovery, put themselves in the shoes of the person who is receiving the discovery request and truthfully answered the question of whether they would regard the discovery request as reasonable or proportionate (if they were the person receiving it).
In this Court’s opinion, this should be one of the first questions which a litigant should ask itself before it frames a discovery application. If the discovery request is not reasonable or proportionate, when so viewed, then that should be end of the discovery request in that form.
As this Court does not regard Category 1A as proportionate, it will not be ordered.
Indeed, this would be the case even if there was not affidavit evidence, which there is, that the costs of such a search going back through almost a quarter of a century of records could, according to ADS, be in excess of €1.9 million, which illustrates how this category of discovery, if granted, runs completely contrary to the one of the stated aims of discovery i.e. to discover ‘documents which are relevant and necessary for disposing fairly of the matter or for saving costs’ (emphasis added), per Sanfey J. in Ryanair v Skyscanner Ltd and Others [2025] IEHC 320, at para. 156.
Thus, as discovery has to be proportionate, a proportionate discovery, in this Court’s view, is Category 1B alone (but excluding the words ‘not falling under Category 1A’).
This Court does not understand ADS to be relying on confidentiality in relation to Category 1B, which are documents it will, in case, be relying upon.
Category 3 (vi)
Cubic sought discovery from ADS of the following category:
35. The background to this category is that the question of whether or not ADS supplies a service, as distinct from just goods, is an issue in this case. However, it seems to this Court that a search of electronic documents going back nearly a quarter of a century (for every single document making any reference whatsoever to ADS’s provision of the StormTech attenuation systems service) would require a very good reason. In Biogen Inc. v Celltrion
Inc. [2018] IEHC 239, at para. 4, where the relevant discovery timeframes which were requested were ‘14 and 22-year periods’, Barrett J. held that such timeframes would require
‘very explicit justification’. This case involves a time-range of even longer than the one considered by Barrett J., namely 24 years. This Court does not believe that there is sufficient justification for such a time frame. Indeed, it is genuinely difficult for this Court to see how
Cubic, in suggesting such a broad trawl through documents, could not have seen how unreasonable this is, as a request for discovery. Of course, it is possible that a document could turn up from 24 years ago that is relevant to these proceedings. However, this amounts, in this Court’s opinion, to making discovery the search for perfect truth, which was deprecated by the Supreme Court,5 without any regard to how reasonable such a request is and to any sense of proportion. As noted by Fennelly J. the ‘public interest in the proper administration of justice is not confined to the relentless search for perfect truth.
The just and proper conduct of litigation also encompasses the objectives of expedition and economy.’
## Would requesting party regard request as reasonable/proportionate if it was recipient?
36. In this regard, and as a general point, in this Court’s view, a lot of discovery requests would disappear or be radically amended, if litigants who look for discovery, put themselves in the shoes of the person who is receiving the discovery request and truthfully answered the question of whether they would regard the discovery request as reasonable or proportionate (if they were the person receiving it).
37. In this Court’s opinion, this should be one of the first questions which a litigant should ask itself before it frames a discovery application. If the discovery request is not reasonable or proportionate, when so viewed, then that should be end of the discovery request in that form.
38. As this Court does not regard Category 1A as proportionate, it will not be ordered.
39. Indeed, this would be the case even if there was not affidavit evidence, which there is, that the costs of such a search going back through almost a quarter of a century of records could, according to ADS, be in excess of €1.9 million,6 which illustrates how this category of discovery, if granted, runs completely contrary to the one of the stated aims of discovery i.e. to discover ‘documents which are relevant and necessary for disposing fairly of the
5 Ryanair Plc v Aer Rianta Cpt [2003] 4 I.R. 264 at pg. 277 per Fennelly J. 6 Affidavit dated 23 March, 2026 of Karim Amin, the Manager of International Sales and Exports of ADS at para 37.
## matter or for saving costs’ (emphasis added), per Sanfey J. in Ryanair v Skyscanner Ltd
and Others [2025] IEHC 320, at para. 156.
40. Thus, as discovery has to be proportionate, a proportionate discovery, in this Court’s view, is Category 1B alone (but excluding the words ‘not falling under Category 1A’).
41. This Court does not understand ADS to be relying on confidentiality in relation to Category
1B, which are documents it will, in case, be relying upon.
## Category 3 (vi)
42. Cubic sought discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Communications since 2020 with engineers, designers, and third parties regarding the capabilities, testing, or performance results of the MC3500 and DC780 chambers generally, and in comparisons with competing products, and as against relevant standards and design codes applicable to the European/Irish market.’
In relation to satisfying this category, ADS suggested that a representative sample be provided, so as to avoid the suggestion by Cubic that ADS might be involved in ‘cherry-picking’. Accordingly, ADS has offered the following:
43. In relation to satisfying this category, ADS suggested that a representative sample be provided, so as to avoid the suggestion by Cubic that ADS might be involved in ‘cherrypicking’. Accordingly, ADS has offered the following:
‘A representative sample of communication since 2020 with engineers, designers, and third parties regarding the capabilities, testing, or performance results of the MC 3500 and DC 780 chambers generally, and in comparisons with competing products, and as against relevant standards and design codes applicable to the European/Irish market.’
Cubic‘s response to this offer of a representative sample is that it will be difficult to police this issue. However, this point could be made about all discovery (i.e. how can one be sure that a litigant has not deliberately omitted to disclose a document). It is policed by the fact that there is an onus on the person swearing the discovery affidavit on behalf of ADS to ensure that any such documents are truly representative, failing which he/she will have to answer to the court. In this regard, undoubtedly, ADS’s lawyers will advise the deponent, on behalf of ADS, of the importance of his/her compliance with this obligation.
Thus, this Category will be ordered in the manner suggested by ADS.
Category 3 (vii)
Cubic sought discovery from ADS of the following category:
44. Cubic‘s response to this offer of a representative sample is that it will be difficult to police this issue. However, this point could be made about all discovery (i.e. how can one be sure that a litigant has not deliberately omitted to disclose a document). It is policed by the fact that there is an onus on the person swearing the discovery affidavit on behalf of ADS to ensure that any such documents are truly representative, failing which he/she will have to answer to the court. In this regard, undoubtedly, ADS’s lawyers will advise the deponent, on behalf of ADS, of the importance of his/her compliance with this obligation.
45. Thus, this Category will be ordered in the manner suggested by ADS.
## Category 3 (vii)
46. Cubic sought discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents relating to any intellectual property protection considered, obtained or sought by the Plaintiff for the sub-corrugation features on the MC3500 and DC780 chambers, being any applications for registration of patents, design rights, and copyright, and related correspondence with intellectual property offices, to include third party observations and oppositions to any such applications.’
ADS offered the following category in response:
‘Copies of any applications (including those withdrawn) for registration of patents, design rights, and copyright for the sub-corrugation features on the MC 3500 and DC 780 chambers throughout the world, to include third party observations and oppositions to any such applications.’
In line with Ryanair v Skyscanner Ltd and Others [2025] IEHC 320 at para. 21 (per Sanfey J.) this Court considers that the expression ‘all documents relating to’ is too broad for most categories of discovery and so does not believe that Cubic should be granted discovery in the terms it seeks.
This Court also accepts ADS’s argument that the core of this case does not involve a challenge to the validity of a registered intellectual property right (i.e. where an application for a trademark or patent has been made), nor at the core of this case is a claim by ADS that its products or designs are protected by such a right. Yet Cubic’s category seeks discovery in relation to matters, which would be relevant to such a claim.
Accordingly, the more proportionate discovery is the one offered by ADS, in this Court’s view and this will be ordered.
Category 5
This category is agreed, but the exclusion, in Category 5, of documents captured by Category 7 is not agreed by the parties, for the reasons set out under Category 7. Accordingly, this aspect of Category 5 has to be considered in conjunction with Category 7.
Category 7
Cubic sought discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents created for or by the ADS Ireland Team or sent to them relating to the claim that the Plaintiff has acquired a valuable reputation and goodwill in the State in respect of the get ups of the Sub Corrugation Products, being:-
(i) Branding guidelines and specification of product get-ups specific to the Sub-Corrugation Products;
47. ADS offered the following category in response:
‘Copies of any applications (including those withdrawn) for registration of patents, design rights, and copyright for the sub-corrugation features on the MC 3500 and DC
780 chambers throughout the world, to include third party observations and oppositions to any such applications.’
48. In line with Ryanair v Skyscanner Ltd and Others [2025] IEHC 320 at para. 21 (per Sanfey
J.) this Court considers that the expression ‘all documents relating to’ is too broad for most categories of discovery and so does not believe that Cubic should be granted discovery in the terms it seeks.
49. This Court also accepts ADS’s argument that the core of this case does not involve a challenge to the validity of a registered intellectual property right (i.e. where an application for a trademark or patent has been made), nor at the core of this case is a claim by ADS that its products or designs are protected by such a right. Yet Cubic’s category seeks discovery in relation to matters, which would be relevant to such a claim.
50. Accordingly, the more proportionate discovery is the one offered by ADS, in this Court’s view and this will be ordered.
## Category 5
51. This category is agreed, but the exclusion, in Category 5, of documents captured by
Category 7 is not agreed by the parties, for the reasons set out under Category 7.
Accordingly, this aspect of Category 5 has to be considered in conjunction with Category
7.
## Category 7
52. Cubic sought discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents created for or by the ADS Ireland Team or sent to them relating to the claim that the Plaintiff has acquired a valuable reputation and goodwill in the State in respect of the get ups of the Sub Corrugation Products, being:- (i) Branding guidelines and specification of product get-ups specific to the Sub-
Corrugation Products;
(ii) Instructions, briefs, budgets and materials used to establish brand recognition in the Sub- Corrugation Products’ get-up;
(iii) Market research and consumer perception studies regarding association of the Sub-Corrugations Products’ get-up with the Plaintiff and/or the StormTech brand;
(iv) Non-party recognition, industry commentary, or customer feedback and communications which identify the get-ups of the Sub- Corrugation Products with the Plaintiff;
(iii) Market research and consumer perception studies regarding association of the
Sub-Corrugations Products’ get-up with the Plaintiff and/or the StormTech brand;
(iv) Non-party recognition, industry commentary, or customer feedback and communications which identify the get-ups of the Sub- Corrugation Products with the
Plaintiff;
(v) Any further document the Plaintiff will rely on to establish valuable reputation and goodwill in the State in respect of the get ups of the Sub Corrugation Products.’
While Category 5 deals with marketing of StormTech products, Category 7 deals with the marketing of the sub-corrugation products. According to Cubic’s written legal submissions (at para. 66), if the marketing of the sub-corrugation products (the focus of Category 7) were dealt with in Category 5, rather than in a separate Category 7, the specific assertions that ADS has made regarding the sub-corrugation products ‘would fall of out of focus’. Thus, Cubic seeks to have the sub-corrugation products, which they do not want to fall out of focus, dealt separately in Category 7.
However, this Court agrees with ADS that it is neither reasonable nor proportionate to require ADS to provide Cubic with discrete categories of discovery in order that it can focus on certain sub-categories. The job of reviewers of documents, for the purposes of providing discoverable documents, is to provide relevant documents. The job of the recipient of the discovery is to isolate or focus on documents it regards as important.
Overlapping categories or sub-categorisation, as proposed by Cubic, does not, in general, make the task easier of deciding which documents fall within which category. It is, if anything, likely to increase expense, since it complicates discovery as documents may have to be reviewed and discovered twice, and so makes it more costly, even though as previously noted one of the aims of discovery is ‘saving costs’.
It is also the case that Category 7 is without time limitation, and so applies for up to a quarter of a century. ADS also points out, correctly, that it will be difficult for a reviewer to determine what documents meet the requirement that they relate ‘to the claim that [ADS] has acquired a valuable reputation or goodwill’.
For these reasons, this Court will instead order ADS’s Category 5 alone, but with the deletion of the words ‘other than those captured by Category 7’, as well as the following which has been offered by ADS:
‘(i) Market research and consumer perception studies regarding association of the Sub-Corrugations Products’ get-up with the Plaintiff and/or the StormTech brand;
(ii) Non-party recognition, industry commentary, or customer feedback, and communications which identify the get-ups of the Sub-Corrugation Products with the Plaintiff.’
It will also add to that, subparagraph (v) from Category 7 as proposed by Cubic (set out above), as it is not onerous for ADS to provide documentation which it proposes to rely upon to establish valuable reputation and goodwill.
ADS has also offered to insert the term ‘branding guidelines’ at the start of Category 5(ii), which this Court will order.
Category 8
Cubic sought discovery from ADS of the following category:
53. While Category 5 deals with marketing of StormTech products, Category 7 deals with the marketing of the sub-corrugation products. According to Cubic’s written legal submissions (at para. 66), if the marketing of the sub-corrugation products (the focus of Category 7)
were dealt with in Category 5, rather than in a separate Category 7, the specific assertions that ADS has made regarding the sub-corrugation products ‘would fall of out of focus’.
Thus, Cubic seeks to have the sub-corrugation products, which they do not want to fall out of focus, dealt separately in Category 7.
54. However, this Court agrees with ADS that it is neither reasonable nor proportionate to require ADS to provide Cubic with discrete categories of discovery in order that it can focus on certain sub-categories. The job of reviewers of documents, for the purposes of providing discoverable documents, is to provide relevant documents. The job of the recipient of the discovery is to isolate or focus on documents it regards as important.
55. Overlapping categories or sub-categorisation, as proposed by Cubic, does not, in general, make the task easier of deciding which documents fall within which category. It is, if anything, likely to increase expense, since it complicates discovery as documents may have to be reviewed and discovered twice, and so makes it more costly, even though as previously noted one of the aims of discovery is ‘saving costs’.
56. It is also the case that Category 7 is without time limitation, and so applies for up to a quarter of a century. ADS also points out, correctly, that it will be difficult for a reviewer to determine what documents meet the requirement that they relate ‘to the claim that [ADS]
has acquired a valuable reputation or goodwill’.
57. For these reasons, this Court will instead order ADS’s Category 5 alone, but with the deletion of the words ‘other than those captured by Category 7’, as well as the following which has been offered by ADS:
‘(i) Market research and consumer perception studies regarding association of the Sub-
Corrugations Products’ get-up with the Plaintiff and/or the StormTech brand;
(ii) Non-party recognition, industry commentary, or customer feedback, and communications which identify the get-ups of the Sub-Corrugation Products with the
Plaintiff.’
58. It will also add to that, subparagraph (v) from Category 7 as proposed by Cubic (set out above), as it is not onerous for ADS to provide documentation which it proposes to rely upon to establish valuable reputation and goodwill.
59. ADS has also offered to insert the term ‘branding guidelines’ at the start of Category 5(ii), which this Court will order.
## Category 8
60. Cubic sought discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents which evidence the Plaintiff’s claim in respect of its reputation and goodwill in the State in connection with the name and brand StormTech/STORMTECH for wastewater systems and products:
(a) Being representative samples of distinct:
(i) Communication with customers or potential customers;
(ii) communication with distributors;
(iii) marketing material and advertisements;
(iv) customer testimonials;
(v) trade publications; and
(b) All customer complaints or criticisms and internal or external reports, studies,
or analyses and communications in respect of any recorded failures referring
to Storm Tech products, excluding the documents captured by category 3(viii).’
ADS does not agree to (b), as it points out, correctly in this Court’s view, that this category would impose a disproportionate burden on it, by virtue of the fact that it applies to ‘all’ documents, and not a representative sample, as is the case with (a), and that it applies across almost a quarter of a century. It is also arguably not necessary, since it concerns complaints about a product, for which Cubic was the sole seller until 2024, and so it is likely that if there were complaints about ADS’s product, which was supplied by Cubic, then Cubic would have heard about them.
Furthermore, it would require the provision of commercially sensitive information to a competitor i.e. details of complaints from customers of ADS. It is to be noted that this Court has taken a similar approach to customer complaints made against Cubic (in relation to ADS’s discovery application in Category 4 above). While the position is not identical, since ADS is the plaintiff and it is claiming goodwill in its supply of its products, nonetheless, it too has confidentiality and commercial sensitivity concerns, which need to be protected from a competitor.
Furthermore, the key information sought in (b), is likely to be covered by Category 3(viii) above, which deals with ‘communications…..in respect of any recorded failures’ of the products. Once again, this overlap in categories is likely to complicate the discovery process and make it more expensive.
Hence, this Court agrees with ADS that it is not proportionate or necessary for category (b) to be provided.
Category 9
Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents relating to the Plaintiff’s claimed copyright in drawings, moulds or
prototypes of the StormTech Products (“the Product Designs”), the StormTech
(v) trade publications; and (b) All customer complaints or criticisms and internal or external reports, studies, or analyses and communications in respect of any recorded failures referring to Storm Tech products, excluding the documents captured by category 3(viii).7’
61. ADS does not agree to (b), as it points out, correctly in this Court’s view, that this category would impose a disproportionate burden on it, by virtue of the fact that it applies to ‘all’ documents, and not a representative sample, as is the case with (a), and that it applies across almost a quarter of a century. It is also arguably not necessary, since it concerns complaints
7 Category 3(viii) was agreed between the parties and it is ‘Documents evidencing or referring to the design, development, engineering, testing, performance and advantages of the MC3500 and DC780 StormTech chambers by the Plaintiff, being [….] (viii) Internal and external reports, studies, or analyses and communications by and/or to the ADS Ireland Team in respect of any recorded failures of the MC3500 and DC780 chambers in the European/Irish market.’ about a product, for which Cubic was the sole seller until 2024, and so it is likely that if there were complaints about ADS’s product, which was supplied by Cubic, then Cubic would have heard about them.
62. Furthermore, it would require the provision of commercially sensitive information to a competitor i.e. details of complaints from customers of ADS. It is to be noted that this Court has taken a similar approach to customer complaints made against Cubic (in relation to
ADS’s discovery application in Category 4 above). While the position is not identical, since
ADS is the plaintiff and it is claiming goodwill in its supply of its products, nonetheless, it too has confidentiality and commercial sensitivity concerns, which need to be protected from a competitor.
63. Furthermore, the key information sought in (b), is likely to be covered by Category 3(viii)
above, which deals with ‘communications…..in respect of any recorded failures’ of the products. Once again, this overlap in categories is likely to complicate the discovery process and make it more expensive.
64. Hence, this Court agrees with ADS that it is not proportionate or necessary for category (b)
to be provided.
## Category 9
65. Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents relating to the Plaintiff’s claimed copyright in drawings, moulds or prototypes of the StormTech Products (“the Product Designs”), the StormTech
Catalogues and Installation Guides (“the StormTech Marketing and Instructional
Materials”) being:-
(i) Design briefs (and any amendments thereto) and development reports for the
development and manufacture of the StormTech Products, including the Sub
Materials”) being:- (i) Design briefs (and any amendments thereto) and development reports for the development and manufacture of the StormTech Products, including the Sub
Corrugation Products and their prototypes, to include any designs consulted, or considered, modified or abandoned, and any commentary on the basis for same, during the course of that process, but excluding any documents captured by Category 3(i) and (ii);
(ii) Documents including the design briefs and any communications in respect of them which are sufficient to evidence the constituent elements of, and the production and design of the StormTech Marketing and Instructional Materials (where such constituent elements comprise a distinct Work for the purpose of section 2 of the Copyright and Related Rights Act, 2000 and are Works over which the Plaintiff claims copyright protection);
(iii) A spreadsheet listing the works in respect of which the Plaintiff claims copyright protection which are found in the Product Designs and the StormTech Marketing and Instructional Materials, which states the creator(s) corresponding to such Work, along with:
(iii) A spreadsheet listing the works in respect of which the Plaintiff claims copyright protection which are found in the Product Designs and the StormTech
Marketing and Instructional Materials, which states the creator(s)
corresponding to such Work, along with:
(a) Documents sufficient to evidence or record the ownership or otherwise of each Work over which the Plaintiff claims copyright, such documents to include but not be limited to project/design proposals, statements of work, contracts, and specifications;
(b) A copy of each such Work; and
(iv) A sample employment/contractor or contract/assignment agreement showing the terms and conditions under which copyright vests in the Plaintiff.’
ADS proposed the following category instead:
‘(i) Design briefs which are sufficient to evidence the production and design of the Storm Tech Marketing and Instructional Materials;
(ii) A spreadsheet listing the works in respect of which the Plaintiff claims copyright protection which are found in the Product Designs and Storm Tech Marketing and Instructional Materials, which states the creator(s) corresponding to such Work, along with:
(b) A copy of each such Work; and (iv) A sample employment/contractor or contract/assignment agreement showing the terms and conditions under which copyright vests in the Plaintiff.’
66. ADS proposed the following category instead:
‘(i) Design briefs which are sufficient to evidence the production and design of the
Storm Tech Marketing and Instructional Materials;
(ii) A spreadsheet listing the works in respect of which the Plaintiff claims copyright protection which are found in the Product Designs and Storm Tech Marketing and
Instructional Materials, which states the creator(s) corresponding to such Work, along with:
(a) Documents sufficient to evidence or record the ownership or otherwise of each Work over which the Plaintiff claims copyright;
(b) A copy of each such Work; and
(c) A sample employment/contractor or contract/assignment agreement showing the terms and conditions under which copyright vests in the Plaintiff.’
Firstly, it is to be noted that Cubic’s proposed category seeks in effect ‘all’ documents relating to the ADS’s alleged copyright claim. In addition, Category 3 already provides for all ‘research and development documents records for the MC3500 and DC 780 chambers’. Hence this overlaps with Category 3 (as evidenced by the insertion of the words ‘excluding any documents captured by Category 3(i) and (ii)’).
Accordingly, this Court believes that the more proportionate category is that suggested by ADS, subject to the insertion of ‘(and communication in relation thereto)’ after the word ‘briefs’ on the first line, which also reflects what Cubic’s interest in seeing communications around design briefs (see para 74 of their written submissions). Access to communications is relevant to an analysis of subsistence and title of copyright because under s 17(6) of the Copyright and Related Rights Act 2000, copyright ‘shall not subsist in a work which is, or to the extent that it is, a copy taken from a work which has been previously made available to the public.’
Category 10
Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents evidencing or referring to the Plaintiff’s assertion that the Defendant has copied the Plaintiff’s stormwater chambers in its design, development, or manufacturing of its RT-720 Chamber and RT-1140 Chamber to include but not limited to:-
(i) All internal and external communications, including emails, memos, reports and
meeting notes, relating to the concept, design, or development of the Defendant’s
(b) A copy of each such Work; and (c) A sample employment/contractor or contract/assignment agreement showing the terms and conditions under which copyright vests in the Plaintiff.’
67. Firstly, it is to be noted that Cubic’s proposed category seeks in effect ‘all’ documents relating to the ADS’s alleged copyright claim. In addition, Category 3 already provides for all ‘research and development documents records for the MC3500 and DC 780 chambers’.
Hence this overlaps with Category 3 (as evidenced by the insertion of the words ‘excluding any documents captured by Category 3(i) and (ii)’).
68. Accordingly, this Court believes that the more proportionate category is that suggested by
ADS, subject to the insertion of ‘(and communication in relation thereto)’ after the word
‘briefs’ on the first line, which also reflects what Cubic’s interest in seeing communications around design briefs (see para 74 of their written submissions). Access to communications is relevant to an analysis of subsistence and title of copyright because under s 17(6) of the
Copyright and Related Rights Act 2000, copyright ‘shall not subsist in a work which is, or to the extent that it is, a copy taken from a work which has been previously made available to the public.’
## Category 10
69. Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents evidencing or referring to the Plaintiff’s assertion that the Defendant has copied the Plaintiff’s stormwater chambers in its design, development, or manufacturing of its RT-720 Chamber and RT-1140 Chamber to include but not limited to:- (i) All internal and external communications, including emails, memos, reports and meeting notes, relating to the concept, design, or development of the Defendant’s
RT-720 Chamber and RT-1140 Chamber, to include documents which:
(a) draw a comparison with the Plaintiff’s StormTech products, including any
reference to the desirability or validity of any intellectual property claim;
and/or
(b) identify, discuss or refer to design drawings, CAD files, technical specifications, models or other works relating to the Plaintiff’s stormwater chambers which the Plaintiff suspects have been copied by the Defendant, such that the Plaintiff had grounds to raise this claim; and/or
(c) identify the features of the Cubic M3 Chambers which are said by the
Plaintiff to have been reproduced by the Defendant from the works
identified at (b);
(a) draw a comparison with the Plaintiff’s StormTech products, including any reference to the desirability or validity of any intellectual property claim;
and/or (b) identify, discuss or refer to design drawings, CAD files, technical specifications, models or other works relating to the Plaintiff’s stormwater chambers which the Plaintiff suspects have been copied by the Defendant, such that the Plaintiff had grounds to raise this claim; and/or (c) identify the features of the Cubic M3 Chambers which are said by the
Plaintiff to have been reproduced by the Defendant from the works identified at (b);
(ii) A schedule set out on affidavit enumerating each document set out at (i)(b), where any such documents are referred to only in documents over which privilege is claimed;
(iii) Documents evidencing the alleged transmission of the works listed at (i)(b) to the
Defendant so that they might be allegedly copied by them.’
Cubic says that this category simply asks ADS ‘what do you say CubicM3 copied?’ and so any documents regarding same should be discovered.
However, this discovery category is much wider than that, in this Court’s view, as it is aimed at matters which are not relevant to the core issue in this case. That core issue (in a copyright context) is what did Cubic do in creating the RainSafe products. It is not what did ADS do or think, which is the focus of this category.
In addition, the bulk of these documents are likely to be privileged since they are concerned with what ADS subjectively believes Cubic did, or why ADS believes that, which is not relevant to the key focus of this case – namely the actions of Cubic.
Hence this category will be refused.
Category 11
Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents evidencing or referring to the arrangement and/or express or implied agreement between the parties for CubicM3 to distribute and promote the StormTech Products in Ireland, including but not limited to the registration and use of the business name "StormTech" and domain name "StormTech.ie", which documents should include any:-
(i) Internal or external communications, including emails, memoranda, text messages, presentations, attendances or meeting notes referencing the business name “StormTech” being provided to or used by Cubic M3;
70. Cubic says that this category simply asks ADS ‘what do you say CubicM3 copied?’ and so any documents regarding same should be discovered.
71. However, this discovery category is much wider than that, in this Court’s view, as it is aimed at matters which are not relevant to the core issue in this case. That core issue (in a copyright context) is what did Cubic do in creating the RainSafe products. It is not what did ADS do or think, which is the focus of this category.
72. In addition, the bulk of these documents are likely to be privileged since they are concerned with what ADS subjectively believes Cubic did, or why ADS believes that, which is not relevant to the key focus of this case – namely the actions of Cubic.
73. Hence this category will be refused.
## Category 11
74. Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘Documents evidencing or referring to the arrangement and/or express or implied agreement between the parties for CubicM3 to distribute and promote the StormTech
Products in Ireland, including but not limited to the registration and use of the business name "StormTech" and domain name "StormTech.ie", which documents should include any:- (i) Internal or external communications, including emails, memoranda, text messages, presentations, attendances or meeting notes referencing the business name “StormTech” being provided to or used by Cubic M3;
(ii) Business plans, marketing materials, or promotional materials referencing the business name "StormTech” being provided to, or used by, CubicM3;
(iii) Emails (and attachments thereto), memoranda and reports sent to or by the ADS Ireland Team recording or discussing CubicM3’s role in respect of growing the StormTech brand in Ireland and elsewhere;
(iii) Emails (and attachments thereto), memoranda and reports sent to or by the
ADS Ireland Team recording or discussing CubicM3’s role in respect of growing the StormTech brand in Ireland and elsewhere;
(iv) Communications or reports discussing the Plaintiff’s trademark in Ireland;
(v) Opinions or internal analysis on potential trademark conflicts with CubicM3’s use of the StormTech brand in Ireland.’
The issue in relation to this category is whether the term used should be ‘arrangement and/or agreement’ (suggested by ADS) or ‘arrangement and/or express or implied agreement’ (suggested by Cubic).
It seems to this Court that what ADS has offered, namely a reference to an ‘arrangement and/or agreement’ to distribute the StormTech products, is sufficiently broad to encompass details which might give rise to an implied agreement, which is the expression used in the pleadings (i.e. ‘without the express or implied permission of’ ADS).
In this Court’s view, it really is a minor issue whether a category of discovery should refer to an ‘arrangement or agreement’ between the parties or whether it should refer to an 'arrangement and/or express or implied agreement’ between the parties. It is arguably a distinction, without any great difference, since a reviewer doing the discovery is not likely to be tasked with looking for an ‘implied agreement’, since by its very nature any such implied agreement is not going to be stated to be such. Thus, the acceptance or rejection of the words ‘express or implied’ do not greatly change the position for either party, in this Court’s view. Accordingly, this Court will not include the term ‘express or implied’ in this category.
Category 13
Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘All documents relating to the claim that the distinctiveness of the Sub-Corrugation Products and their goodwill has been damaged, being:-
(i) Internal communications including emails, reports, memoranda referring to the alleged impact of CubicM3’s RT-720 Chamber and the RT-1140 Chamber on the Plaintiff’s StormTech Products in Ireland and/or on the Plaintiff’s StormTech brand, product distinctiveness, or customer base;
(ii) Documents evidencing measures taken by the Plaintiff and its associates and distributors in Ireland to mitigate the Plaintiff’s alleged losses since the introduction of the sale by CubicM3 of its RT-720 Chamber and the RT-1140 Chambers, or actions taken by the Plaintiff to protect or restore the distinctiveness or goodwill of the Plaintiff’s products.’
ADS offers discovery of the following category:
(v) Opinions or internal analysis on potential trademark conflicts with
CubicM3’s use of the StormTech brand in Ireland.’
75. The issue in relation to this category is whether the term used should be ‘arrangement and/or agreement’ (suggested by ADS) or ‘arrangement and/or express or implied agreement’ (suggested by Cubic).
76. It seems to this Court that what ADS has offered, namely a reference to an ‘arrangement and/or agreement’ to distribute the StormTech products, is sufficiently broad to encompass details which might give rise to an implied agreement, which is the expression used in the pleadings (i.e. ‘without the express or implied permission of’ ADS).
77. In this Court’s view, it really is a minor issue whether a category of discovery should refer to an ‘arrangement or agreement’ between the parties or whether it should refer to an
'arrangement and/or express or implied agreement’ between the parties. It is arguably a distinction, without any great difference, since a reviewer doing the discovery is not likely to be tasked with looking for an ‘implied agreement’, since by its very nature any such implied agreement is not going to be stated to be such. Thus, the acceptance or rejection of the words ‘express or implied’ do not greatly change the position for either party, in this
Court’s view. Accordingly, this Court will not include the term ‘express or implied’ in this category.
## Category 13
78. Cubic seeks discovery from ADS of the following category:
‘All documents relating to the claim that the distinctiveness of the Sub-Corrugation
Products and their goodwill has been damaged, being:- (i) Internal communications including emails, reports, memoranda referring to the alleged impact of CubicM3’s RT-720 Chamber and the RT-1140 Chamber on the
Plaintiff’s StormTech Products in Ireland and/or on the Plaintiff’s StormTech brand, product distinctiveness, or customer base;
(ii) Documents evidencing measures taken by the Plaintiff and its associates and distributors in Ireland to mitigate the Plaintiff’s alleged losses since the introduction of the sale by CubicM3 of its RT-720 Chamber and the RT-1140 Chambers, or actions taken by the Plaintiff to protect or restore the distinctiveness or goodwill of the
Plaintiff’s products.’
79. ADS offers discovery of the following category:
‘All documents relating to the claim that the distinctiveness of the Sub-
Corrugation Products and their goodwill has been damaged, being:-
(i) Internal communications with the ADS Ireland Team including emails, reports, memoranda referring to the alleged impact of CubicM3’s RT-720 Chamber and the RT-1140 Chamber on the Plaintiff’s StormTech Products in Ireland and/or on the Plaintiff’s StormTech brand, product distinctiveness, or customer base;
Corrugation Products and their goodwill has been damaged, being:- (i) Internal communications with the ADS Ireland Team including emails, reports, memoranda referring to the alleged impact of CubicM3’s RT-720 Chamber and the RT-
1140 Chamber on the Plaintiff’s StormTech Products in Ireland and/or on the
Plaintiff’s StormTech brand, product distinctiveness, or customer base;
(ii) Documents evidencing measures taken by the Plaintiff and its associates and distributors in Ireland to mitigate the Plaintiff's alleged losses since the introduction of the sale by CubicM3 of its RT-720 Chamber and the RT-1140 Chamber.’
This Court agrees with ADS that the unqualified reference to ‘internal communications’ is broader than is necessary and will necessitate a search that is unnecessarily burdensome (i.e. to include the worldwide employees of ADS). In addition, it seems highly likely that material which is sought by Cubic under this heading will be captured by a reference to ‘internal communications with the ADS Ireland Team’ (which has been accepted by Cubic as sufficient for other categories) and so it seems to this Court that expanding the subjects of the search beyond the ADS Ireland Team is not necessary in this category.
This Court does however agree that it is relevant and not too burdensome on ADS to include any attempts by it to ‘protect or restore the distinctiveness or goodwill of’ ADS’s products, as suggested by Cubic.
Hence Cubic’s category will be ordered, but with paragraph (i) of ADS’s category replacing paragraph (i) in Cubic’s category.
APPLICATION FOR INSPECTION BY ADS OF CUBIC’S PIPES
ADS seeks five samples of the Cubic’s RainSafe RT-1140 Chamber and five samples of its RainSafe RT-720 Chamber. It also seeks 50 lbs/23 kg of the coloured raw material that Cubic uses in the manufacture of these chambers. It does so under Order 50, rule 4 of the Rules of the Superior Courts, which states:
80. This Court agrees with ADS that the unqualified reference to ‘internal communications’ is broader than is necessary and will necessitate a search that is unnecessarily burdensome (i.e. to include the worldwide employees of ADS). In addition, it seems highly likely that material which is sought by Cubic under this heading will be captured by a reference to
‘internal communications with the ADS Ireland Team’ (which has been accepted by Cubic as sufficient for other categories) and so it seems to this Court that expanding the subjects of the search beyond the ADS Ireland Team is not necessary in this category.
81. This Court does however agree that it is relevant and not too burdensome on ADS to include any attempts by it to ‘protect or restore the distinctiveness or goodwill of’ ADS’s products, as suggested by Cubic.
82. Hence Cubic’s category will be ordered, but with paragraph (i) of ADS’s category replacing paragraph (i) in Cubic’s category.
## APPLICATION FOR INSPECTION BY ADS OF CUBIC’S PIPES
83. ADS seeks five samples of the Cubic’s RainSafe RT-1140 Chamber and five samples of its RainSafe RT-720 Chamber. It also seeks 50 lbs/23 kg of the coloured raw material that
Cubic uses in the manufacture of these chambers. It does so under Order 50, rule 4 of the
Rules of the Superior Courts, which states:
‘The Court, upon the application of any party to a cause or matter, and upon such terms as may be just, may make any order for the detention, preservation, or inspection of any property or thing, being the subject of such cause or matter, or as to which any question may arise therein, and for all or any of the purposes aforesaid may authorise any person to enter upon or into any land or building in the possession of any party to such cause or matter and for all or any of the purposes aforesaid may authorise any samples to be taken or any observations to be made or experiment to be tried, which may be necessary or expedient for the purpose of obtaining full information or evidence.’
It is clear from Bula Ltd v Tara Mines Ltd (No.1) [1987] I.R. 85 that a plaintiff, in a case like this is free to use the court procedure of inspection irrespective of the ‘strength of the plaintiff’s case’ and is not required to produce evidence or verify his cause of action, in order to obtain inspection. Thus, the starting point in an application like this is that, subject to confidentiality concerns/legitimate commercial interests, a litigant is entitled to inspection of products which he/she needs or where expedient for the case
It is also to be noted that ADS has indicated that it is willing to pay Cubic for the chambers and raw material and to return same to Cubic, save to the extent that it may have been subject to destructive testing.
The background to this application for inspection is summarised by Cubic in its written submissions, namely that ADS claims that Cubic:
‘has engaged in passing off and copyright infringement of the design of [ADS’] yellow StormTech stormwater attenuation chambers by virtue of CubicM3’s more recently designed and novel RainSafe stormwater attenuation chambers, which are green.’
For its part, Cubic points out that at para 13(c)(ii) of its Defence, that its chambers:
84. It is clear from Bula Ltd v Tara Mines Ltd (No.1) [1987] I.R. 85 that a plaintiff, in a case like this is free to use the court procedure of inspection irrespective of the ‘strength of the plaintiff’s case’ and is not required to produce evidence or verify his cause of action, in order to obtain inspection. Thus, the starting point in an application like this is that, subject to confidentiality concerns/legitimate commercial interests, a litigant is entitled to inspection of products which he/she needs or where expedient for the case
85. It is also to be noted that ADS has indicated that it is willing to pay Cubic for the chambers and raw material8 and to return same to Cubic, save to the extent that it may have been subject to destructive testing.
8 Transcript Day 3, pg. 80, line 14.
86. The background to this application for inspection is summarised by Cubic in its written submissions, namely that ADS claims that Cubic:
‘has engaged in passing off and copyright infringement of the design of [ADS’] yellow
StormTech stormwater attenuation chambers by virtue of CubicM3’s more recently designed and novel RainSafe stormwater attenuation chambers, which are green.’
87. For its part, Cubic points out that at para 13(c)(ii) of its Defence, that its chambers:
‘are bright green and of different dimensions and weights, provide different storage volumes and have a different corrugation design to [ADS’] yellow products’.
When ADS raised particulars in respect of this aspect of Cubic’s defence, Cubic responded that the foregoing plea was adequate in pleading the difference between the parties’ products and ‘anything further is a matter for evidence’.
Clearly therefore since Cubic has in its own possession the ‘evidence’ to support/undermine this defence (the RainSafe pipes), the principle of equality of arms means that ADS must have an opportunity to inspect Cubic’s chambers. Hence, ADS has sought five samples.
In this regard, Cubic acknowledges that Cubic must grant some inspection rights to ADS. However, as Cubic is a competitor of ADS, and as Cubic seeks to protect its interests in the confidentiality of the design of its products, it is not agreeable to sending samples of the chambers to ADS.
Instead, Cubic offers ADS a visual inspection of the products at its premises. It restricts this inspection to ADS’s lawyers and experts (which Cubic says must be European, although it knows that ADS’s expert is American). It also seems that the inspection must take place in the presence of Cubic personnel. Cubic also requires that the representatives of ADS attending the inspection would not be able to video the inspection and, it seems, that their notes would, subject to redaction, be reviewed by Cubic.
This Court does not believe that Cubic’s approach is sufficient to ensure that there is equality of arms, when it comes to the trial, and it prefers the approach suggested by ADS, with some modifications.
Firstly, this is because this Court does not accept Cubic’s claim that provision of samples of the chambers is not ‘necessary or expedient’ for ADS’s case. This is because it seems to this Court that ADS should be entitled to examine and test, including if it feels appropriate by means of destruction, the design of Cubic products to see if they have been copied from ADS’s products. In particular, this is because Cubic’s Defence is that it has a different corrugation design. It could well be that design features might not be clear from a visual inspection and may require a more detailed examination by machinery or indeed by destruction of the product.
In addition, this Court can see no basis for the suggestion by Cubic that ADS should be restricted to doing whatever tests or examination Cubic allows on its premises and under its watch. In particular, this Court cannot see why ADS should be required to inspect a product in the context of a copyright claim and a passing off claim under the eye of the opposing litigant and presumably for there to be exchanges between ADS’s lawyers and ADS’s expert, within earshot of Cubic personnel.
Furthermore, as part of its passing off claim, ADS is seeking damages to account for the fact, if that be the case, that the products, which are allegedly being passed off, are inferior to those of ADS’s. Evidence for such inferiority, if it existed, is much more likely to be gathered from a thorough testing of the products, including by possible destruction, rather than by a visual inspection under the watch of Cubic.
Cubic responds by stating that without confusion, there is no action in passing off and so no entitlement to damages. Accordingly, Cubic suggests that this case is all about confusion and so all about appearances, for which a visual inspection is sufficient. Nonetheless, if confusion is established, then damages may be calculated taking account of the inferior quality of the Cubic products (if they are inferior). Hence the relevance of ADS being given the opportunity to test the quality of the product, which will not be possible, at all, or to a limited extent, if it is restricted to a visual inspection at Cubic’s premises. In this regard, ADS relied on the statement of Lord Blackburn in Singer Manufacturing Co. v Loog (1882) 8 App Cas 15, 29-30 regarding the foundation of the law of passing off:
88. When ADS raised particulars in respect of this aspect of Cubic’s defence, Cubic responded that the foregoing plea was adequate in pleading the difference between the parties’ products and ‘anything further is a matter for evidence’.
89. Clearly therefore since Cubic has in its own possession the ‘evidence’ to support/undermine this defence (the RainSafe pipes), the principle of equality of arms means that ADS must have an opportunity to inspect Cubic’s chambers. Hence, ADS has sought five samples.
90. In this regard, Cubic acknowledges that Cubic must grant some inspection rights to ADS.
However, as Cubic is a competitor of ADS, and as Cubic seeks to protect its interests in the confidentiality of the design of its products, it is not agreeable to sending samples of the chambers to ADS.
91. Instead, Cubic offers ADS a visual inspection of the products at its premises. It restricts this inspection to ADS’s lawyers and experts (which Cubic says must be European, although it knows that ADS’s expert is American). It also seems that the inspection must take place in the presence of Cubic personnel.9 Cubic also requires that the representatives
9 Transcript Day 3, pg. 45, lines 25-29: ‘So I am to conduct a privileged engagement on the Defendant's premises, I'm to bring my product in full view of the Defendants and carry out what would otherwise be a, in a privilege sense, hermetically sealed and protected engagement between the solicitors, the expert and my client’.
of ADS attending the inspection would not be able to video the inspection and, it seems, that their notes would, subject to redaction, be reviewed by Cubic.10
92. This Court does not believe that Cubic’s approach is sufficient to ensure that there is equality of arms, when it comes to the trial, and it prefers the approach suggested by ADS, with some modifications.
93. Firstly, this is because this Court does not accept Cubic’s claim that provision of samples of the chambers is not ‘necessary or expedient’ for ADS’s case. This is because it seems to this Court that ADS should be entitled to examine and test, including if it feels appropriate by means of destruction, the design of Cubic products to see if they have been copied from
ADS’s products. In particular, this is because Cubic’s Defence is that it has a different corrugation design. It could well be that design features might not be clear from a visual inspection and may require a more detailed examination by machinery or indeed by destruction of the product.
94. In addition, this Court can see no basis for the suggestion by Cubic that ADS should be restricted to doing whatever tests or examination Cubic allows on its premises and under its watch. In particular, this Court cannot see why ADS should be required to inspect a product in the context of a copyright claim and a passing off claim under the eye of the opposing litigant and presumably for there to be exchanges between ADS’s lawyers and
ADS’s expert, within earshot of Cubic personnel.
95. Furthermore, as part of its passing off claim, ADS is seeking damages11 to account for the fact, if that be the case, that the products, which are allegedly being passed off, are inferior to those of ADS’s. Evidence for such inferiority, if it existed, is much more likely to be
10 Transcript Day 3, pgs. 46-47. 11 Affidavit of Colette Brady, solicitor to ADS, dated 25 February 2026, para. 20.
gathered from a thorough testing of the products, including by possible destruction, rather than by a visual inspection under the watch of Cubic.
96. Cubic responds by stating that without confusion, there is no action in passing off and so no entitlement to damages. Accordingly, Cubic suggests that this case is all about confusion and so all about appearances, for which a visual inspection is sufficient. Nonetheless, if confusion is established, then damages may be calculated taking account of the inferior quality of the Cubic products (if they are inferior). Hence the relevance of ADS being given the opportunity to test the quality of the product, which will not be possible, at all, or to a limited extent, if it is restricted to a visual inspection at Cubic’s premises. In this regard,
ADS relied on the statement of Lord Blackburn in Singer Manufacturing Co. v Loog (1882)
8 App Cas 15, 29-30 regarding the foundation of the law of passing off:
‘The original foundation of the whole law is this, that when one knowing that goods are not made by a particular trader sells them as and for the goods of that trader, he does that which injures that trader. At first it was put upon the ground that he did so when he sold inferior goods as and for the trader's; but it is established (alike at law: Blofeld v. Payne …, and in equity: Edelsten v. Edelsten 4 B. & Ad. 410, and in equity: Edelsten v Edelsten 1 D. J. & S. 185, that it is an actionable injury to pass off goods known not to be the plaintiff's as and for the plaintiff's, even though not inferior.’
However, as pointed out by ADS, if the goods in question are inferior, this is relevant (albeit that if they are not inferior, one can still have an action in passing off). This is because the alleged inferiority of the goods may assist a plaintiff in establishing the three elements of the tort of passing off (i.e. goodwill on the part of the plaintiff, misrepresentation by the defendant and damage to the plaintiff) and in particular the ‘damage’ element of the tort.
Nonetheless, this Court is cognisant of the fact that Cubic has a legitimate interest in protecting its confidential information regarding the design of its chambers, which should be protected, if possible. As noted by Costello J. in James Elliott Construction Ltd v Lagan [2015] IEHC 631, at para 12, ‘inspection… should be facilitated if it can be achieved while at the same time protecting the interests of the opposing party’. On the other hand, of course, as noted by Noonan J. in Murphy Environmental Ltd v Spencer Place Development Company Ltd [2020] IECA 78, at para. 30, ‘the underlying rationale for inspection orders is to ensure equality of arms’.
In this Court reaching its decision as to where the balance lies between protecting the legitimate commercial interests of Cubic and ensuring that there is, in fact, an equality of arms between Cubic and ADS when it comes to the trial of this action, the following factors are important.
Firstly, it is not disputed that between 2003 and 2024 Cubic had the same (or very similar) access to ADS’s chambers (in Cubic’s role as a distributor of those products), as ADS is now refusing to grant Cubic, now that Cubic is in competition with ADS, i.e. Cubic would have had for 20 years full access to samples of ADS’s products.
Secondly, it is the case that any third party can currently purchase one of Cubic’s chambers (as part of the purchase of water attenuation system from Cubic). Thus, Cubic’s pipes are already out in the public and so the claim that they should be treated as constituting confidential information is considerably weakened by this fact.
It is true that in many, if not most, cases the purchaser may not examine or test the chambers being inserted in his/her lands. This is because, as pointed out by Cubic ‘RainSafe chambers are not on display to be admired. They are buried underground’. However, that does not change the pipes’ legal status (as being owned by the third party purchasers of the water attenuation system from Cubic). Accordingly, those third party purchasers can do exactly what ADS is asking to do, namely examine and test those products, and/or apply destructive testing to them. Indeed, that third party could remove them from the ground and provide them to a third party, without any involvement of Cubic. These are not the characteristics of a confidential product, such that one can refuse to provide a sample of same to a party claiming that it breaches copyright.
To put the issue in general terms, it seems to this Court that once Cubic sells its pipes to third parties, they cease, in a practical sense and broadly speaking, to be confidential. How could they be confidential, when the purchaser can do what it likes with those products? Yet, at the same time, Cubic is saying that those very same products are so confidential that ADS is not entitled to get a sample and must restrict itself to a visual inspection under the eye of Cubic.
Thirdly, it is also important to note that there is no claim by Cubic that it obtains a confidentiality clause or other restrictive covenant from purchasers of its water attenuation system regarding their use of Cubic’s chambers. This is a further reason why it is difficult to see how confidentiality can be said to subsist in respect of the chambers.
Fourthly, as already noted, while the alleged inferiority of the RainSafe chambers (which is more adequately tested by destruction), is not a requirement in order to establish whether there has been a passing off (since the appropriation of goodwill is sufficient to establish damage), it could be a factor in establishing the extent of any damage.
Fifthly, if this Court did not order ADS to provide the samples, it would mean that there would be an inequality of arms regarding the trial. This is because Cubic would have in its possession, and could choose to use, the samples, as it likes for the purpose of defending the proceedings. However, in that situation, ADS would be restricted to a visual inspection of those samples, and would only get to see the samples at the trial, if Cubic chooses to use them at trial. In a passing off/copyright action, this cannot, in this Court’s view, amount to an equality of arms.
Accordingly, this Court would order that five samples be provided. However, it believes that some protection can be provided for Cubic’s confidentiality in its design process and its legitimate commercial interests, by not ordering the provision of the raw material.
In doing so, it is respecting the commercially sensitive information belonging to Cubic. As noted by Simons J. in Carlisle Mortgages Ltd v Heagney [2019] IEHC 108, at para 28 it:
97. However, as pointed out by ADS, if the goods in question are inferior, this is relevant (albeit that if they are not inferior, one can still have an action in passing off). This is because the alleged inferiority of the goods may assist a plaintiff in establishing the three elements of the tort of passing off (i.e. goodwill on the part of the plaintiff, misrepresentation by the defendant and damage to the plaintiff) and in particular the ‘damage’ element of the tort.
98. Nonetheless, this Court is cognisant of the fact that Cubic has a legitimate interest in protecting its confidential information regarding the design of its chambers, which should be protected, if possible. As noted by Costello J. in James Elliott Construction Ltd v Lagan
[2015] IEHC 631, at para 12, ‘inspection… should be facilitated if it can be achieved while at the same time protecting the interests of the opposing party’. On the other hand, of course, as noted by Noonan J. in Murphy Environmental Ltd v Spencer Place Development
Company Ltd [2020] IECA 78, at para. 30, ‘the underlying rationale for inspection orders is to ensure equality of arms’.
99. In this Court reaching its decision as to where the balance lies between protecting the legitimate commercial interests of Cubic and ensuring that there is, in fact, an equality of arms between Cubic and ADS when it comes to the trial of this action, the following factors are important.
100. Firstly, it is not disputed that between 2003 and 2024 Cubic had the same (or very similar) access to ADS’s chambers (in Cubic’s role as a distributor of those products), as
ADS is now refusing to grant Cubic, now that Cubic is in competition with ADS, i.e. Cubic would have had for 20 years full access to samples of ADS’s products.
101. Secondly, it is the case that any third party can currently purchase one of Cubic’s chambers (as part of the purchase of water attenuation system from Cubic). Thus, Cubic’s pipes are already out in the public and so the claim that they should be treated as constituting confidential information is considerably weakened by this fact.
102. It is true that in many, if not most, cases the purchaser may not examine or test the chambers being inserted in his/her lands. This is because, as pointed out by Cubic ‘RainSafe chambers are not on display to be admired. They are buried underground’. However, that does not change the pipes’ legal status (as being owned by the third party purchasers of the water attenuation system from Cubic). Accordingly, those third party purchasers can do exactly what ADS is asking to do, namely examine and test those products, and/or apply destructive testing to them. Indeed, that third party could remove them from the ground and provide them to a third party, without any involvement of Cubic. These are not the characteristics of a confidential product, such that one can refuse to provide a sample of same to a party claiming that it breaches copyright.
103. To put the issue in general terms, it seems to this Court that once Cubic sells its pipes to third parties, they cease, in a practical sense and broadly speaking, to be confidential.
How could they be confidential, when the purchaser can do what it likes with those products? Yet, at the same time, Cubic is saying that those very same products are so confidential that ADS is not entitled to get a sample and must restrict itself to a visual inspection under the eye of Cubic.
104. Thirdly, it is also important to note that there is no claim by Cubic that it obtains a confidentiality clause or other restrictive covenant from purchasers of its water attenuation system regarding their use of Cubic’s chambers. This is a further reason why it is difficult to see how confidentiality can be said to subsist in respect of the chambers.
105. Fourthly, as already noted, while the alleged inferiority of the RainSafe chambers (which is more adequately tested by destruction), is not a requirement in order to establish whether there has been a passing off (since the appropriation of goodwill is sufficient to establish damage),12 it could be a factor in establishing the extent of any damage.
106. Fifthly, if this Court did not order ADS to provide the samples, it would mean that there would be an inequality of arms regarding the trial. This is because Cubic would have in its possession, and could choose to use, the samples, as it likes for the purpose of defending the proceedings. However, in that situation, ADS would be restricted to a visual inspection of those samples, and would only get to see the samples at the trial, if Cubic chooses to use them at trial. In a passing off/copyright action, this cannot, in this Court’s view, amount to an equality of arms.
12 Polycell Products Ltd v O’Carroll [1959] I.R. 342.
107. Accordingly, this Court would order that five samples be provided. However, it believes that some protection can be provided for Cubic’s confidentiality in its design process and its legitimate commercial interests, by not ordering the provision of the raw material.
108. In doing so, it is respecting the commercially sensitive information belonging to Cubic.
As noted by Simons J. in Carlisle Mortgages Ltd v Heagney [2019] IEHC 108, at para 28 it:
‘may also be appropriate to attach conditions to an order for inspection so as to respect any commercially sensitive information’.
In particular, it will not order the provision of the raw materials, because this case is, for the most part, one of passing off and copyright, which primarily, but not exclusively, is based on appearances. For this reason, this Court believes that the provision of the samples alone achieves the correct balance between the competing interests of the two parties. Support for this view is to be found in the fact that a member of the public is not entitled to purchase raw materials and so the request for samples of raw material, is of a very different nature from the request of samples of the chambers themselves. Another way to put it is that Cubic allows its chambers to leave its premises and go to the outside world without restriction (and so there is no reason why ADS should not be entitled to samples of same), but Cubic does not allow its raw materials to leave its premises in the same manner (and so ADS is not entitled to samples of same).
While this Court does not believe that Cubic has any right to restrict ADS’s choice of expert by nationality or domicile, this Court does believe that some further protection can be provided to Cubic regarding its fears about the misuse of its confidential information.
This can be done by providing that the inspection and testing of Cubic’s products must take place in this jurisdiction and that all records relating to the inspection must be retained here. In this way, there is a greater likelihood of breaches of confidentiality, if any, being detected and of course, the Irish courts would have a greater ability to police and seek to remedy any breaches of confidentiality, where everything happens and is stored within this jurisdiction.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, this Court will order the categories of discovery as set out above, subject to confidentiality arrangements to be agreed between the parties, and the forgoing provision of samples of the products to ADS for inspection, also subject to confidentiality arrangements to be agreed.
This matter will be put in for mention a week from its delivery at 10.45 a.m. to deal with any final orders and costs. However, on the assumption that it should not be necessary to expend costs on a further court sitting, and in order to facilitate the parties agreeing all outstanding matters, the parties have liberty to notify the Registrar if such a listing proves to be unnecessary. This is particularly so in light of the clear implication from Word Perfect Translation Services Ltd v Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform [2023] IECA 189 at para. 94, that there is an onus on lawyers to take a broad-brush approach to costs.
109. In particular, it will not order the provision of the raw materials, because this case is, for the most part, one of passing off and copyright, which primarily, but not exclusively, is based on appearances. For this reason, this Court believes that the provision of the samples alone achieves the correct balance between the competing interests of the two parties.
Support for this view is to be found in the fact that a member of the public is not entitled to purchase raw materials and so the request for samples of raw material, is of a very different nature from the request of samples of the chambers themselves. Another way to put it is that Cubic allows its chambers to leave its premises and go to the outside world without restriction (and so there is no reason why ADS should not be entitled to samples of same), but Cubic does not allow its raw materials to leave its premises in the same manner (and so
ADS is not entitled to samples of same).
110. While this Court does not believe that Cubic has any right to restrict ADS’s choice of expert by nationality or domicile, this Court does believe that some further protection can be provided to Cubic regarding its fears about the misuse of its confidential information.
111. This can be done by providing that the inspection and testing of Cubic’s products must take place in this jurisdiction and that all records relating to the inspection must be retained here. In this way, there is a greater likelihood of breaches of confidentiality, if any, being detected and of course, the Irish courts would have a greater ability to police and seek to remedy any breaches of confidentiality, where everything happens and is stored within this jurisdiction.
## CONCLUSION
112. For the foregoing reasons, this Court will order the categories of discovery as set out above, subject to confidentiality arrangements to be agreed between the parties, and the forgoing provision of samples of the products to ADS for inspection, also subject to confidentiality arrangements to be agreed.
113. This matter will be put in for mention a week from its delivery at 10.45 a.m. to deal with any final orders and costs. However, on the assumption that it should not be necessary to expend costs on a further court sitting, and in order to facilitate the parties agreeing all outstanding matters, the parties have liberty to notify the Registrar if such a listing proves to be unnecessary. This is particularly so in light of the clear implication from Word Perfect
Translation Services Ltd v Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform [2023] IECA 189 at para. 94, that there is an onus on lawyers to take a broad-brush approach to costs.