{"check":null,"uid":"eb8f464dc0b6f839","title":"Trevor Spears v The Information Commissioner & Anor","title_generated":false,"country":"Великобритания","organ":"Суды Англии и Уэльса","kind":"case","kind_name":"Судебная практика","lang":"en","date":"2026-10-27","summary":"Суд рассмотрел апелляцию гражданина против решения Информационного комиссара отказать в предоставлении информации о результатах исследования продукции компании, проведённого органами торговли и стандартов. Рассмотрение касалось применения Закона о свободе информации 2000 года. Суд пришёл к выводу, что публичный интерес в сохранении конфиденциальности результатов расследования перевешивает общественный интерес в прозрачности действий органов власти, особенно с учётом необходимости защиты способности властей эффективно выполнять свои функции.","snippet":"","topics":["Персональные данные"],"status":"ok","error":"","text_len":56995,"versions":1,"url":"https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukftt/grc/2026/1482","first_seen":"2026-10-28","last_checked":"2026-11-16 05:32","relevance":"hit","score":3,"query":"personal data","source_key":"caselaw_uk","verdict":{"relevance":"hit","score":3,"topics":["Персональные данные"],"need_body":3,"authorities":[{"kind":"орган","name":"Information Commissioner","topic":"Персональные данные"},{"kind":"орган","name":"ICO","topic":"Персональные данные"}],"evidence":[{"topic":"Персональные данные","term":"Information Commissioner","weak":false,"pos":20,"ctx":"Trevor Spears v The Information Commissioner & Anor 1.  This is an appeal against a decision of the Information Commissioner (“the Com","zone":"орган","weight":3},{"topic":"Персональные данные","term":"ICO","weak":false,"pos":1218,"ctx":"t or obtained by Trading Standards concerning products sold by [business name redacted by ICO] or [business name redacted by ICO] between 1 September 2020 and today’s date, including","zone":"орган","weight":0}],"dropped":[{"topic":"Персональные данные","term":"data protection","weak":false,"pos":7375,"ctx":"h, any reference to the company or its commercial products did not meet the threshold for personal data protection under section 40 of the foia or for confidentiality under section 41 of the foia.  12.  t","why":"одиночное упоминание (нужно 3)"}]},"last_changed":"2026-10-28","meta":{"neutralCitation":"[2026] UKFTT 01482 (GRC)","court":"United Kingdom First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber)"},"source_url":"https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukftt/grc/2026/1482","text":"1.\n\nThis is an appeal against a decision of the Information Commissioner (“the Commissioner”) dated 15 April 2026, reference IC-400579-F2L4 (“the Decision Notice”).\n\n2.\n\nThe parties opted for a paper determination of the appeal. The Tribunal is satisfied that it can properly determine the issues without a hearing in accordance with rule 2 and rule 32(1)(b) of The Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal)(General Regulatory Chamber) Rules 2009 (as amended).\n\nFactual background\n\n3.\n\nThe appeal relates to the application of the\nFreedom of Information Act 2000\n(“the FOIA”). It concerns a request for information made to Cambridgeshire County Council (“the Council”).\n\nThe request and response\n\n4.\n\nThe request which is the subject of this appeal was made on 08 May 2025 in writing. The request related to information concerning an investigation by Trading Standards into a specified business – which, for the purposes of this appeal shall be referred to as “Company X” - and requested information as follows:\n\n“1.\n\nAny and all chemical analysis or testing reports carried out or obtained by Trading Standards concerning products sold by [business name redacted by ICO] or [business name redacted by ICO] between 1 September 2020 and today’s date, including but not limited to the aforementioned reagents.\n\n2.\n\nThe name or label of the specific products tested and the names of any reagents examined.\n\n3.\n\nThe chemical composition and concentration of substances identified in the tests, especially concentrations of sulfuric acid.\n\n4.\n\nThe name(s) of the laboratory or organisation(s) that conducted such testing.\n\n5.\n\nInternal documentation, correspondence, or records relating to:\n\na.\n\nThe decision-making process for concluding whether or not the tested products were compliant with UK regulations (\nOffensive Weapons Act 2019\n).\n\nb.\n\nThe interpretation of the 15% sulfuric acid concentration threshold and any related assessments regarding public sale”.\n\n5.\n\nIn relation to the public interest, the Appellant stated\n“Given the potential regulatory and public safety implications of these products, particularly concerning the high concentration of sulfuric acid and public accessibility, there is a strong and overriding public interest in transparency”.\nThe Appellant requested that the public interest test be clearly documented and disclosed if applicable.\n\n6.\n\nBy way of background, the Appellant had made a complaint to the Council five years previously regarding the composition of a reagent sold by Company X. An investigation had been undertaken by Trading Standards, which entailed the testing of specific reagents produced by Company X to determine whether an offence contrary to the\nOffensive Weapons Act 2019\nhad been committed. Investigations by both the Council and the police concluded that no criminal charges should be brought. No concerns had been raised by the Council or the police as to the validity of the laboratory tests that had been carried out. The Appellant had been made aware of the outcome of the investigations\n\n7.\n\nThe Council responded on 06 June 2025. It stated that the duty to confirm or deny whether it held the requested information had been deemed not to apply, in line with section 30(3) of the FOIA. The Council stated as follows:\n\n“The investigation undertaken by Trading Standards was undertaken in line with the statutory powers held by the team as a regulatory body.\n\nThe investigation was undertaken to ascertain whether anyone working at [name redacted] should be charged with an offence under the\nOffensive Weapons Act 2019\n.\n\nThe information which you have requested, be it held or not, is exempt as it would have been obtained or created by the authority for the purposes of its functions as described above”.\n\n8.\n\nNotwithstanding that it neither confirmed nor denied whether the requested information was held, the Council outlined their considerations in relation to the public interest test. The Council accepted that there was a strong public interest in understanding how Trading Standards carry out its investigations and how decisions are made. It recognised that public scrutiny of the quality of decisions could increase public confidence in those decisions, and would also ensure heightened accountability on the part of the Council. Disclosure would demonstrate the thoroughness of investigations conducted by Trading Standards and would demonstrate how public resources are allocated during an investigation.\n\n9.\n\nConversely, the Council also identified a strong public interest in not compromising the ability of Trading Standards to undertake investigations. The approach by Trading Standards to inspections and enforcement was published on the Council’s website to provide transparency on the work that was done. There was a strong public interest in enabling Trading Standards to undertake its responsibilities in an efficient and effective manner, and it would not be in the public interest to disclose information which would prejudice this function.\n\n10.\n\nThe Council concluded that the balance of the public interest lay in withholding the information, in order to preserve the investigative and enforcement abilities of Trading Standards.\n\n11.\n\nThe Appellant wrote to the Council on 06 June 2025 to request an internal review, stating that the application of section 30(3) of the FOIA to issue a “neither confirm nor deny” response was\n“misplaced and disproportionate in this context”.\nThe Appellant requested that the Council reconsider their refusal for the following reasons:\n\ni.\n\nThe investigation that had been conducted by Trading Standards was now closed, and so disclosure could not prejudice ongoing or prospective proceedings;\n\nii.\n\nThe Council’s reliance on section 30(3) of the FOIA was not applicable in circumstances where the Council had already confirmed that testing of the reagents occurred and that the results were shared with Cambridgeshire Police;\n\niii.\n\nThe tested products appeared to fall under two regimes – Trading Standards being responsible for enforcement under the\nOffensive Weapons Act 2019\n, and the police being responsible for enforcement under the\nPoisons Act 1972\n. Enforcement had been declined by both authorities on the basis of shared conclusions from a single lab report, in circumstances where the integrity of that report was in question;\n\niv.\n\nThere was a significant public interest in how Trading Standards evaluated compliance with controlled substance laws, as well as in the quality of its investigative procedures and the basis on which Trading Standards declined to take enforcement action;\n\nv.\n\nThe harms cited by the Council were speculative and not proportionate to the information that had actually been requested;\n\nvi.\n\nThe Appellant had submitted independent third-party laboratory analysis to Trading Standards which confirmed that the reagents in questions contained sulfuric acid concentrations far in excess of the legal public sale limit of 15%;\n\nvii.\n\nSection 30 of the FOIA could not be used to conceal flawed decision-making, especially once a matter was closed;\n\nviii.\n\nThe identity of the company whose products were tested, and the name of its director and registered office, were already published on the Companies House register. As such, any reference to the company or its commercial products did not meet the threshold for personal data protection under section 40 of the FOIA or for confidentiality under section 41 of the FOIA.\n\n12.\n\nThe Council provided the outcome of its internal review on 02 July 2025, stating as follows:\n\ni.\n\nIt was noted that the Appellant was aware that investigations into the complaint had been closed, and was also aware of the outcome of both the Trading Standards investigation and the investigation by Cambridgeshire Police. As such, the Council had reviewed the case and considered that it was not appropriate to rely on section 30(3) of the FOIA to neither confirm nor deny that the Council held information pertaining to the request;\n\nii.\n\nHaving revised their answer, the Council asserted that the information held was subject to section 30(1)(a) of the FOIA and stated that it was applying the exemption to the information requested;\n\niii.\n\nThe Council stated that the information requested had been created in order to investigate a criminal offence and used to determine whether a person should be charged with an offence. It was not necessary for the investigation to lead to someone being charged with or convicted of an offence in order for the exemption to be engaged;\n\niv.\n\nThe Council undertook a public interest balancing test, outlining factors in favour and against disclosure. In favour of disclosure, the Council again identified the strong public interest in transparency and accountability, particularly where public funds were concerned, and in the importance of increasing public understanding and confidence in decisions made by Trading Standards;\n\nv.\n\nFactors identified by the Council in favour of not disclosing the information included the strong public interest in not compromising the ability of Trading Standards to undertake investigations which were designed to protect consumers and members of the public, and the impact on cooperation with Trading Standards by companies or individuals if it was understood that the outcome or tests would be published. Information in relation to the Council’s approach to inspections and enforcement was already in the public domain to improve transparency. It was also noted that there was a strong public interest in enabling Trading Standards to carry out their responsibilities efficiently and effectively and that, as the outcome of the investigations by both the police and Trading Standards was the same, the public could take reassurance from the fact that both investigating bodies had reached the same conclusion;\n\nvi.\n\nThe Council stated\n“We consider that the public interest is in favour of withholding the information as wider public interest is served by enabling Trading Standards to undertake efficient and robust investigations with companies who will engage in providing evidence to the council. This would not be achieved should companies feel that the council would publish evidence, reports and outcomes of its investigation to such a level [of] detail as you have requested”\n;\n\nvii.\n\nThe Council also determined that the information sought in questions 1-3, namely the analysis of the products, engaged the exemption in section 43(2) of the FOIA regarding prejudice to the commercial interests of any person. It noted that Company X was selling a product with a unique design and that, should any other competitor or company gain access to the chemical composition of the products, they would be able to reproduce the product, undercut Company X by charging lower prices, and thus remove that company’s ability to make a profit;\n\nviii.\n\nThe Council carried out a public interest balancing test, noting arguments regarding transparency, accountability and openness which favoured disclosure. It also noted that, whilst it had been argued that there were potential regulatory and public safety implications to the products, the products had been deemed to be compliant with legislation and therefore the Council could properly attribute a lower degree of public interest to providing the information;\n\nix.\n\nIn considering the public interest factors against disclosure, the Council noted that it was not in the public interest to threaten the commercial position of a company or to prejudice their ability to turn a profit. In addition, if companies believed that the council would share its commercial and/or confidential information – such as the chemical composition and concentration of their products – with the wider public then they would be less willing to engage with the Council.\n\nx.\n\nIn relation to the application of section 43(2) of the FOIA, the Council concluded that there was a significant risk of prejudice to the commercial interests of Company X and that the balance of the public interest lay in withholding the information to protect their commercial interests to allow the maintenance of fair commercial competition.\n\n13.\n\nThe internal review therefore concluded that the requested information was subject to the exemptions in both section 30(1)(a) and section 43(2) of the FOIA, and that the public interest test in each case was in favour of withholding the requested information.\n\nThe complaint and the Commissioner’s investigation\n\n14.\n\nThe Appellant lodged a complaint with the Commissioner on 04 July 2025, stating that he disagreed with the Council’s refusal to provide the requested information. The Appellant stated that\n“I am dissatisfied because Cambridgeshire Trading Standards confirmed they hold the information I requested (chemical test results and related regulatory records) but refused to disclose it, citing Section 30(1)(a) and Section 43(2). I believe these exemptions are misapplied as the investigation is closed and there is an overriding public interest in disclosure given serious public safety and compliance concerns. I also provided independent lab evidence showing likely non-compliance, and the reagents themselves act as acid concentration indicators. I would like the ICO to require disclosure or partial/redacted release in line with FOIA public interest obligations”.\n\n15.\n\nThe complaint was accepted for consideration on 22 July 2025 and was confirmed as being under investigation on 05 February 2026.\n\n16.\n\nThe Commissioner wrote to the Council on 05 February 2026 and invited the Council to review the way in which the request had been handled. The Council was asked to respond to a series of questions in relation to the exemptions relied upon and the factors that had been taken into account in favour of disclosing the information and in favour of maintaining one or more of the exemptions.\n\n17.\n\nThe Council responded to the Commissioner on 26 February 2026. The Council provided further background to their engagement with the Appellant which had been ongoing since 2020. In August 2021, the Appellant had notified the Council that he had applied a product from Company X to his arm/hand and had suffered serious burns, which he attributed to acid in the formulation. He stated that his attending doctor in hospital had asked for details of the product’s contents. The Appellant was informed that the Council could not release formulation details via a patient and said that, if the clinician required the information, he would need to contact Trading Standards via official channels to request it. A further similar request was made by the Appellant the same day, with the same response being given by the Council. The Council stated that\n“Given the circumstances and the lack of follow-up, the Trading Standards Service’s assumption was that this may have been an attempt to obtain proprietary information about the composition of a competitor’s product rather than a genuine medical request”.\nThe Appellant had been invited to submit a corporate complaint if he was dissatisfied with the outcome of the assessment completed by Trading Standards but, to date, had not pursued that course of action.\n\n18.\n\nIn relation to the specific questions that had been asked by the Commissioner, the Council’s response, in summary, was as follows:\n\ni.\n\nThe Council provided the Commissioner with test house certificates, stating that the relevant samples had been sent to an external laboratory for analysis. The certificates confirmed that the tested products made by Company X were not in breach of statutory requirements;\n\nii.\n\nThe Council confirmed that, following a complaint by the Appellant in July 2020, Trading Standards had undertaken an investigation into a reagent being produced by Company X. Company X had provided samples of their products which had then been sent to an external, accredited laboratory for testing. The investigation into Company X had been completed by the time of the Appellant’s FOIA request although the Council noted that, if further complaints relating to the same company were received in the future, any documentation created in the course of the initial investigation may be used in any subsequent litigation;\n\niii.\n\nThe primary aim of the Trading Standards service of the Council was to protect customers and enforce Trading Standards law. Part of that duty was to ensure product safety and undertake relevant investigations to ensure that products are safe for public consumption. On receiving the complaint from the Appellant, a Trading Standards officer undertook an investigation in line with the powers conferred under Schedule 5 to the\nConsumer Rights Act 2015\n. As part of the investigation into whether the products were safe or whether any individual working for Company X should be charged with an offence, the officer commissioned a report to identify whether the chemical composition of the products was safe;\n\niv.\n\nThe withheld information comprised of six test house certificates which included details of the analysis of samples provided by Company X; the name of the specific products tested and reagents examined; the chemical composition and concentration of substances identified in the tests; and the name of the organisation conducting the testing;\n\nv.\n\nThe Council relied on the public interest arguments that had been outlined in their response to the request for an internal review in favour of disclosing the information. They also stated that they were mindful of promoting openness and transparency in the discharge of their statutory functions, and that disclosure of the information could result in an increase in public confidence in the Council’s ability to protect and safeguard individuals. The Council further noted that disclosing information relating to how it performed its investigations could assist businesses in understanding how the Council operated, thereby allowing for more collaborative work between businesses and Trading Standards;\n\nvi.\n\nThe Council relied on the public interest arguments that had been outlined in their response to the request for an internal review in favour of maintaining the exemption. In addition, they referred to an inherent public interest in maintaining the integrity of the information as evidence in the event that future legal or enforcement action was required, and also relied on the fact that, as an accredited report had confirmed that there was no safety risk, there was not a high public interest in the documentation being disclosed to the public;\n\nvii.\n\nIn carrying out the public interest balance test, the Council highlighted that the testing reports had determined that the products were safe and that therefore the argument that the public had a need to see the reports was not significant. Conversely, Trading Standards needed to have the ability to properly conduct their investigations and, if the information was disclosed, it may decrease the cooperation by businesses with Trading Standards which would have a detrimental impact on its ability to protect and safeguard the public;\n\nviii.\n\nIn relation to section 43(2) of the FOIA, the Council’s position was that disclosure of the six test house certificates would have a prejudicial effect on Company X, as the documents contained information relating to the chemical composition of a product produced by them. The composition of the product was a trade secret, and the product had a unique selling point of being the only product on the market of this consistency. The Council stated that\n“A competitor equipped with the withheld information, would put them at a targeted advantage and this would lead to a significant loss of profit”\n. The Council concluded that the prejudice that would be caused by disclosure of the withheld information was real and of substance, and that there was a causal relationship between disclosure and the prejudice itself;\n\nix.\n\nThe Council concluded that, as the products had been deemed safe for public consumption, disclosure would not contribute towards public safety and would instead prejudice Company X’s commercial interests.\n\n19.\n\nOn 09 April 2026, the Commissioner wrote to the Council to ask whether the Council had intended to rely on section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA, rather than on section 30(1)(a), on the basis that the Council had a ‘power’ to investigate under the\nOffensive Weapons Act 2019\nrather than a ‘duty’.\n\n20.\n\nOn 15 April 2026, the Council wrote to the Commissioner to confirm that it was indeed a ‘power’, and that therefore they wished to proceed with reliance on section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA.\n\nDecision notice\n\n21.\n\nThe Decision Notice was issued on 15 April 2026.\n\n22.\n\nThe Commissioner’s decision was that the Council was entitled to refuse to disclose the withheld information in accordance with section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA and that the public interest lay in maintaining the exemption.\n\n23.\n\nOn the basis of his decision, the Commissioner had not found it necessary to consider the Council’s application of section 43(2) of the FOIA.\n\n24.\n\nThe Commissioner did not require the Council to take any further steps, although he did remind the Council of the importance of identifying and citing the correct limb of an exemption when it is relying on any section of the FOIA.\n\n25.\n\nThe Commissioner was satisfied that the Council has the power to undertake investigations for the purposes of Schedule 5 of the\nConsumer Rights Act 2015\n, including into the safety of a product and whether any offence has been committed under the\nOffensive Weapons Act 2019\n.\n\n26.\n\nHaving reviewed the withheld information, the Commissioner was satisfied that the Council had come to hold it for the purposes of its Trading Standards investigation into products sold by Company X.\n\n27.\n\nThe Commissioner was therefore satisfied that section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA was engaged.\n\n28.\n\nWhen assessing the public interest balance, the Commissioner accepted that there was a public interest in the Council demonstrating transparency in its decision-making processes and in increasing confidence in law enforcement. There was also a public interest in demonstrating that the Council’s enforcement and prosecution actions had been carried out fairly and appropriately.\n\n29.\n\nHowever, the Commissioner highlighted that a key consideration was whether disclosure could compromise a public authority’s ability to carry out its investigative work effectively, noting the strong public interest in the Council being able to regulate and enforce compliance with the law.\n\n30.\n\nThe Commissioner recognised that, even though public authorities usually had enforcement powers to require information to be provided, such powers were most effective when used sparingly and that reliance was instead placed on the voluntary cooperation of victims and witnesses. If parties were not able to provide information in confidence for the purposes of an investigation, the Commissioner was satisfied that would impact on the voluntary flow of information that the Council relied upon in such investigations.\n\n31.\n\nWhilst the investigation into Company X was complete at the time of the Appellant’s request, the Commissioner recognised that information held for that investigation may be used in any future investigations or proceedings against the company.\n\n32.\n\nThe Commissioner acknowledged\n“the complainant’s concerns and the basis for them; however, [the] Commissioner observes that the Council has conducted an investigation as the proper authority under the legislation, and the findings of that investigation was that no enforcement action is necessary. Whilst another party has reached a different conclusion about the safety of the product, this is not in itself evidence that the Council’s investigation is flawed”.\n\n33.\n\nThe Commissioner therefore found that the application of the public interest test supported the exemption in section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA being maintained.\n\nGrounds of appeal\n\n34.\n\nThe Appellant lodged his appeal on 23 April 2026. The Appellant acknowledged that section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA was capable of being engaged and therefore confined his appeal to the Commissioner’s conclusion that the public interest favoured withholding all of the requested information.\n\n35.\n\nThe Appellant put forward grounds of appeal as follows:\n\ni.\n\nInsufficient weight was given to the fact that the investigation into Company X was closed at the time of his request. The Appellant submitted that there was less weight in favour of withholding information relating to a concluded investigation than to a live one;\n\nii.\n\nThe Commissioner relied too heavily on speculative future harm – he accepted that the information may be used in future investigations or proceedings, notwithstanding that no future investigations or proceedings were identified. The Appellant argued that, if almost all information from a closed investigation could be withheld indefinitely on the basis that it might be useful again in future, this would give an excessively broad effect to the operation of section 30 of the FOIA;\n\niii.\n\nThe decision placed too much weight on concerns around voluntary cooperation. Whilst voluntary cooperation may be preferable, the Council had statutory compulsory powers in relation to the provision of information which weakened any claim that disclosure from a concluded investigation would materially impair future investigations;\n\niv.\n\nThe Commissioner did not properly consider partial disclosure, given that the request covered different categories of information. For example, the decision upholding the withholding of the entirety of the requested information did not properly distinguish between the identity of the products tested, methodology, summary conclusions, and whether sulfuric acid was found above or below the legal threshold;\n\nv.\n\nThe Commissioner gave insufficient weight to issues relating to public safety and accountability. The Appellant’s independent analysis which disagreed with the Council’s conclusions was not designed to prove, in itself, that the Council’s investigation was flawed, but rather to demonstrate and strengthen the case for transparency, accountability and scrutiny;\n\nvi.\n\nThe Council initially relied on section 30(3), then section 30(1)(a), and then finally on section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA. Whilst the shifting position did not carry significant weight on its own, the Appellant submitted that it did undermine confidence that the refusal to disclose the information was carefully and correctly framed from the outset.\n\n36.\n\nThe remedy sought was for the Tribunal to set aside the Decision Notice and to find that the Commissioner had erred in concluding that the public interest favoured withholding all of the requested information pursuant to section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA. The Appellant asked the Tribunal to require reconsideration of the request on the basis that proper weight be given to the fact that the investigation was closed, the speculative nature of the asserted future harm, the Council’s statutory investigative powers, the public safety and accountability issues, and the possibility of partial or redacted disclosure. In the alternative, the Appellant asked the Tribunal to substitute a decision requiring disclosure of those parts of the requested information that could properly be disclosed in full, redacted or summarised form.\n\nThe response of the Commissioner\n\n37.\n\nThe Commissioner lodged his response to the appeal on 18 May 2026, resisting the appeal and relying on his findings and reasons as set out in the Decision Notice. The Commissioner noted that the sole question before the Tribunal was whether the Commissioner erred in law in concluding that the public interest in maintaining the exemption under section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA outweighed the public interest in disclosure of the withheld information.\n\n38.\n\nThe Commissioner’s response, in summary, read as follows:\n\ni.\n\nThe purpose of section 30 of the FOIA was to preserve the ability of public authorities to carry out effective investigations. As such, the key consideration in any section 30 case was to determine whether the disclosure could in some way compromise a public authority’s ability to carry out its investigative work effectively;\n\nii.\n\nGround one: Whilst closure of an investigation may reduce the weight in maintaining the exemption in some cases, the public interest required assessment of whether disclosure could still compromise investigative functions, including through the re-use of material in future matters. The fact that information held for the closed investigation into Company X may be used in any future investigation or proceedings against the company legitimately formed part of the Commissioner’s assessment as part of the balancing exercise;\n\niii.\n\nGround two: The Commissioner’s view was that there was a risk of several actual harms that might occur as a result of disclosure of the requested material, relating to whether the Council’s ability to carry out its investigative work effectively could be compromised. The Commissioner found no basis to conclude that he had improperly engaged in speculation beyond a necessary assessment of the potential harms that may be caused by disclosure;\n\niv.\n\nGround three: It was entirely legitimate and appropriate for the Commissioner to take the fact that voluntary cooperation remained a significant aspect of the investigative arsenal of a public authority into account;\n\nv.\n\nGround four: The Commissioner was satisfied that section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA was engaged for the entirety of the withheld information and that the factors established in favour of maintaining the exemption would be undermined if any of the information was released;\n\nvi.\n\nGround five: Whilst the Commissioner considered the Appellant’s submissions about the potential impact on public safety in light of the Appellant’s report, the Commissioner was entitled to conclude that it did not outweigh the systemic public interest in protecting investigative functions. The Commissioner did recognise that there may be additional significance where disclosure would reveal flaws in a public authority’s investigation, but found that the contrary third-party report, without more, did not evidence a flawed investigation;\n\nvii.\n\nGround six: The appeal was against the Decision Notice, not the reasoning of the Council. In addition, the fact that the Council raised a different exemption following an internal review was not an error of law and could not be taken into account. The Commissioner had undertaken his own assessment of the application of section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA and had found that it applied.\n\n39.\n\nThe Commissioner concluded by maintaining that he was correct to conclude that the public interest in maintaining the exemption under section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA outweighed the public interest in disclosure of the withheld information.\n\nThe reply of the Appellant\n\n40.\n\nThe Appellant’s reply was lodged on 04 June 2026, and is summarised as follows:\n\ni.\n\nThe Appellant confirmed that the only live issue in the appeal was the public interest balance under section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA;\n\nii.\n\nThe Commissioner’s response did not identify any concrete reason as to why a concluded investigation justified withholding all of the requested material;\n\niii.\n\nThe reliance on possible future investigations or proceedings remained speculative, and the reasoning risked justifying the indefinite withholding of information from any closed investigation;\n\niv.\n\nThe Commissioner had continued to overstate the weight to be attached to the importance of voluntary cooperation;\n\nv.\n\nThe response failed to analyse whether any distinct category of information could be disclosed in redacted or summarised form;\n\nvi.\n\nThe relevance of the Appellant’s analysis report was that\n“credible competing evidence materially increases the public interest in scrutiny of the Council’s conclusions, methodology and reasoning, particularly where the products are sold to the general public and the issue concerns regulated sulfuric acid thresholds”.\n\nGrounds of Opposition on behalf of the Council\n\n41.\n\nThe Council filed written grounds of opposition on 22 June 2026.\n\n42.\n\nThe Council submitted that the completion of an investigation did not automatically negate the applicability of the protections afforded under section 30 of the FOIA. It confirmed that, as a public authority, the Council was necessarily dependent upon the voluntary cooperation of members of the public with its investigations. Undermining the willingness of individuals to engage with the Council would be likely to affect the Council’s ability to discharge their functions to provide appropriate protections to the public effectively, which was not in the public interest.\n\n43.\n\nThe Council also pointed to the distinction between private interests and public interests, stating that\n“it is submitted that disclosure of the test certificates would not advance any legitimate public interest objective recognised under FOIA. It has already been established that the product in question does not present a danger to the public and accordingly disclosure would not contribute to public safety, regulatory accountability or any wider public-interest purpose”.\n\n44.\n\nThe Council concluded by maintaining its objection to disclosure, submitting that the exemption was properly engaged and that the public interest test had been correctly applied in accordance with the FOIA and relevant case law.\n\nSupplemental reply of the Appellant to the Council’s Grounds of Opposition\n\n45.\n\nThe Appellant filed a supplemental reply to the Council’s grounds of opposition on 23 June 2026, which is summarised as follows:\n\ni.\n\nThe fact that the withheld material consisted of six test house certificates supported the Appellant’s submission that it should be possible for the Tribunal to order partial, redacted or summarised disclosure, particularly in relation to the methodology used, the identity of the products tested, and whether sulphuric acid was detected above or below the relevant threshold;\n\nii.\n\nThere was a lack of clarity as to whether information concerning the level of sulphuric acid and the analyst’s percentage/weight calculation was not held at all, or not held separately from the test house certificates. This lack of clarity reinforced the Appellant’s contention that the Council and Commissioner had approached the request too broadly;\n\niii.\n\nThe fact that the withheld material comprised of test house certificates, rather than witness statements or intelligence material, weakened the Council’s argument as to the importance of voluntary cooperation. In addition, whilst it was recognised by the Appellant that the existence of statutory investigative powers does not remove all value from voluntary cooperation, it did weaken any broad claim that disclosure of laboratory/test certificate information from a closed investigation would materially damage future investigatory effectiveness;\n\niv.\n\nWhilst the Appellant accepted that he had prior commercial experience in the market, the public interest (as opposed to any private interest) in the appeal was substantial. The Appellant’s independent testing report was relied upon to show that there was credible competing evidence and therefore a heightened public interest in scrutiny of the Council’s methodology, conclusions and reasoning;\n\nv.\n\nThe Appellant disputed any suggestion that the history of his correspondence with the Council should reduce the public interest in disclosure, or that his correspondence could be described as threatening;\n\nvi.\n\nThe Appellant concluded by stating\n“The Council’s Grounds do not answer the central point in the appeal; why the whole of a defined set of six test house certificates from a closed investigation must be withheld, without meaningful consideration of partial, redacted or summarised disclosure”.\n\nWitness statement on behalf of the Council\n\n46.\n\nA witness statement from Peter Gell, dated 16 July 2026, was served on behalf of the Council and can be summarised as follows:\n\ni.\n\nPeter Gell was Head of Trading Standards for the Council and a qualified Trading Standards Officer. He had worked in Trading Standards and local authority regulatory services for approximately thirty-six years across five local authorities;\n\nii.\n\nIn his role with the Council, he had overall responsibility for the strategic direction, governance, performance and delivery of the Trading Standards Service (“the Service”). The overarching purpose of the Service was to protect consumers, support legitimate businesses, and maintain confidence in the marketplace;\n\niii.\n\nThe investigation of product safety matters form a routine and significant part of the Service’s work, and the Service will regularly assess the safety and compliance of consumer products and, where appropriate, arrange for products to be subjected to independent scientific analysis or testing;\n\niv.\n\nThe investigatory powers available to Trading Standards officers for the purposes of Regulation 10 of the General Product Safety Regulations 2005 and Part 7 of the\nOffensive Weapons Act 2019\nare contained within Schedule 5 of the\nConsumer Rights Act 2015\n, which provides powers to inspect, require information, enter premises, and secure evidence where appropriate;\n\nv.\n\nWhere a complaint is received about a product, the Service will normally take the following steps:\n\na.\n\nDetermine whether the matter falls within their statutory remit and whether it has a duty or a power to enforce the relevant legislation;\n\nb.\n\nUndertake an initial assessment to determine the nature of the allegations and the extent to which they are supported by evidence;\n\nc.\n\nUndertake proportionate enquiries to establish whether there is a credible risk to consumer safety;\n\nd.\n\nAssess whether there is sufficient evidence to justify further investigation, which may include obtaining samples and arranging independent analysis;\n\ne.\n\nDetermine next steps where non-compliance is identified.\n\nvi.\n\nIn relation to the complaint against Company X, the Service undertook initial enquiries given the potential implications for public safety. Checks against local and national intelligence systems did not raise any concerns or evidence of prior complaints against the product, and nor did enquiries conducted directly with the manufacturer;\n\nvii.\n\nA sample of the product was submitted to an independent public analysist for testing, as officers from the Service are not qualified to undertake expert scientific testing. The analysis undertaken confirmed that the product was compliant and did not present any safety concerns;\n\nviii.\n\nThe findings were reviewed by the investigating officer and considered by Trading Standards managers, who were all satisfied that the investigation had been conducted appropriately, that the enquiries undertaken were proportionate to the circumstances of the case, and that the conclusions reached were supported by the available evidence;\n\nix.\n\nOfficers had also considered the source and reliability of the information provided by the Appellant, who operated within the same commercial market as Company X. Whilst this factor did not prevent the allegations from being investigated, it was considered relevant when assessing the weight that could be attached to the information provided by the Appellant, which in turn is why expert analysis was sought by the Service;\n\nx.\n\nThe withheld information contained detailed technical information relating to the manufacture, composition and performance of Company X’s product. Disclosure of the withheld material would:\n\na.\n\nProvide a direct competitor of Company X with information that could be used to gain a commercial advantage from Company X’s proprietary work;\n\nb.\n\nUndermine the confidence that businesses have in their dealings with regulators, and make them less willing to cooperate openly and voluntarily;\n\nc.\n\nImpair the ability of the Service to carry out its statutory functions effectively through a reduction in voluntary cooperation;\n\nd.\n\nUndermine the integrity of future investigations.\n\nWitness statement on behalf of the Appellant\n\n47.\n\nA witness statement from the Appellant, dated 20 July 2026, was served and can be summarised as follows:\n\ni.\n\nThe Appellant was associated with SafeTest4, which supplied reagent test kits, including of the type relevant to this appeal. The business ceased public sales of the relevant sulfuric/sulphuric acid-based reagents following legislative change which affected the public sale of products containing sulfuric acid above a relevant threshold;\n\nii.\n\nThe Appellant’s concerns about Company X’s products therefore arose from his practical experience in manufacturing and supplying these types of reagents;\n\niii.\n\nThe Appellant had obtained independent laboratory testing of the relevant products made by Company X. The report concluded that the chemical material in the product was highly acidic in nature, and that the estimated content of sulphuric acid in the liquid phase in both samples far exceeded the 15% limit;\n\niv.\n\nWhilst the Appellant accepted that there had been a long history of communications between himself and the Council, it arose from sustained concerns that products being sold to the public were not compliant with the relevant restricted acid threshold and that official conclusions were not consistent with the evidence that was available to him;\n\nv.\n\nIn August 2021, one of the reagents from Company X had been applied to the Appellant’s skin to demonstrate that it was corrosive, which led to a chemical burn;\n\nvi.\n\nThe Appellant was not seeking details of the composition of the products to obtain commercial information for private use, but rather because the composition of the product was directly relevant to understanding the nature of his injury and the public safety risk;\n\nvii.\n\nThe fact that the withheld material contained multiple types of information reinforced the Appellant’s position that the Tribunal should consider whether at least some of it could be disclosed in a redacted or summarised form;\n\nviii.\n\nThe Appellant stated that his reading of the witness statement of Mr Peter Gell was that the samples tested by the Council in relation to Company X’s product were supplied following contact between the Council and Company X, rather than by way of a blind or ordinary public purchase. As such, the provenance and representativeness of the samples were relevant to the public interest balance;\n\nix.\n\nThe Appellant asserted that it should be possible to disclose non-sensitive information, such as the name of the products tested, how the samples were obtained, and the broad methodology without disclosure of any full trade-secret information;\n\nx.\n\nThe Appellant’s witness statement concludes by saying\n“I did have a business interest because my own business ceased public sale of similar reagents following the legislative change. However, the issue I raised with CCC [the Council] also concerned public sale of potentially corrosive chemical products and the consistency and transparency of regulatory enforcement……My position is that the public-interest balance favours at least partial, redacted or summarised disclosure because the withheld material goes to product testing, public safety, sample provenance, and regulatory decision-making concerning products sold to the general public”.\n\n48.\n\nThe Appellant also provided a report titled ‘Analytical Report on the analysis of Chemical Products’, dated 20 June 2022 and prepared by James Hutton Ltd, a company providing analytical laboratory services. The report referenced the analysis of two products to determine whether the concentration of sulphuric acid within the products was below 15%.\n\nGist\n\n49.\n\nA gist was prepared by the Council, dated 27 July 2026, summarising the contents of the closed bundle as follows:\n\ni.\n\nCertificates: Six laboratory reports obtained from an external expert during the Council’s investigation, which contained scientific analysis, evidential findings and expert conclusions that informed the Council’s assessment of product compliance and its consideration as to whether criminal proceedings were appropriate;\n\nii.\n\nCorrespondence from third party: An indication from the third party that it regarded the withheld information as being commercially sensitive and considered that disclosure would cause commercial harm.\n\nLegal Framework\n\n50.\n\nThe general right of access to information pursuant to the FOIA is as follows:\n\ns.1 General right of access to information held by public authorities\n\n(1)\n\nAny person making a request for information to a public authority is entitled –\n\n(a)\n\nto be informed in writing by the public authority whether it holds information of the description specified in the request, and\n\n(b)\n\nif that is the case, to have that information communicated to him.\n\n…….\n\n51.\n\nSection 2 of the FOIA relates to the effect of the exemptions in Part II of\nthe Act\n, which includes the exemption pursuant to section 30, and states as follows:\n\ns.2\nEffect of the exemptions in Part II\n\n(1)\n\n…….\n\n(2)\n\nIn respect of any information which is exempt information by virtue of any provision of Part II, section 1(1)(b) does not apply if or to the extent that –\n\n(a)\n\nthe information is exempt information by virtue of a provision conferring absolute exemption, or\n\n(b)\n\nin all the circumstances of the case, the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information.\n\n52.\n\nThe relevant provisions of the FOIA in relation to investigations and proceedings conducted by public authorities are as follows:\n\ns.30\nInvestigations and proceedings conducted by public authorities\n\n(1)\n\nInformation held by a public authority is exempt information if it has at any time been held by the authority for the purposes of –\n\n(a)\n\nany investigation which the public authority has a duty to conduct with a view to it being ascertained –\n\n(i)\n\nwhether a person should be charged with an offence, or\n\n(ii)\n\nwhether a person charged with an offence is guilty of it,\n\n(b)\n\nany investigation which is conducted by the authority and in the circumstances may lead to a decision by the authority to institute criminal proceedings which the authority has power to conduct, or\n\n(c)\n\nany criminal proceedings which the authority has power to conduct.\n\n(2)\n\n…….\n\n(3)\n\nThe duty to confirm or deny does not arise in relation to information which is (or if it were held by the public authority would be) exempt information by virtue of subsection (1) or (2).\n\n…….\n\n53.\n\nSection 30 of the FOIA is a qualified exemption and is therefore subject to the public interest test outlined above. The public interest balance should be considered as at the time of the response to the request.\n\n54.\n\nThe phrase “at any time” in section 30(1) of the FOIA means that information is exempt under that section if it relates to an ongoing, closed or abandoned investigation.\n\n55.\n\nSection 30 of the FOIA is a class-based exemption, meaning that it is not necessary to demonstrate that disclosure would lead to any kind of prejudice in order to engage the exemption. It is only necessary to demonstrate that the request falls within the class of information that the exemption is designed to protect.\n\n56.\n\nThe relevant provisions of FOIA in relation to commercial interests are:\n\ns.43\nCommercial interests\n\n(1)\n\nInformation is exempt information if it constitutes a trade secret.\n\n(2)\n\nInformation is exempt information if its disclosure under\nthis Act\nwould, or would be likely to, prejudice the commercial interests of any person (including the public authority holding it).\n\n(3)\n\n…….\n\nThe role of the Tribunal\n\n57.\n\nThe Tribunal’s remit is governed by section 58 of FOIA. This requires the Tribunal to consider whether the decision made by the Commissioner is in accordance with the law or, where the Commissioner’s decision involved an exercise of his discretion, whether he ought to have exercised it differently. The Tribunal may receive evidence that was not before the Commissioner and may make different findings of fact from the Commissioner.\n\nIssue\n\n58.\n\nThe issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether the Commissioner was correct in holding that the Council was entitled to rely on section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA to refuse to disclose the withheld information and, if so, whether the public interest lay in maintaining the exemption.\n\nEvidence\n\n59.\n\nWe read and took account of an open bundle containing 123 pages including indexes. We also read and took account of a closed bundle submitted by the Council which is held pursuant to a Rule 14(6) direction.\n\nDiscussions and conclusions\n\n60.\n\nThe first limb for the Tribunal to determine is whether the exemption in section 30(1) of the FOIA is engaged in this case. We note that the withheld information in this case comprises of six test house certificates which were generated during the course of an investigation conducted by the Trading Standards Service of the Council. We have considered Schedule 5 of the\nConsumer Rights Act 2015\nand are satisfied that it confers a power on the Council to conduct an investigation into the safety of a product and also into whether any offence has been committed under the\nOffensive Weapons Act 2019\n. We are further satisfied that the Council holds the withheld information for the purposes of an investigation that it conducted and in circumstances which may have led to a decision by the authority to institute criminal proceedings which the authority had the power to conduct.\n\n61.\n\nWe therefore conclude that the exemption in section 30(1) of the FOIA is engaged. The Tribunal notes that all parties to the appeal agree that the exemption is so engaged.\n\n62.\n\nThe Tribunal has then turned to consider the public interest test, and in particular whether the Commissioner was correct to uphold the Council’s determination that the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighed the public interest in disclosing the information.\n\n63.\n\nThe Tribunal recognises the importance of accountability and transparency in how the Council fulfils its statutory functions. As well as assisting businesses in understanding how the Council operates such investigations, openness also serves to increase public confidence in how the Council conducts investigations and enforcement, and how they protect and safeguard the public.\n\n64.\n\nWhen considering the issue of transparency, we found the statement of Mr Peter Gell to be of considerable assistance. In his statement, he details the approach taken by the Council to investigations concerning product safety more broadly, and also in relation to the specific investigation against Company X. We therefore attach significant weight to his statement in terms of the process followed by the Council and the conclusions that were reached. We are satisfied that the volume and detail of the information already disclosed satisfies the requirement for transparency, which is underscored by the publication of material on the Council’s website.\n\n65.\n\nThe Tribunal has considered the Appellant’s submission that the existence of the analysis report that he had obtained, which reaches a different outcome to that reached by the Council, increases the public interest in disclosure and in scrutiny of the Council’s conclusions and methodology. However, as accepted by the Appellant, the mere fact that a different analysis has reached a different conclusion does not mean that the Council’s investigation was flawed. In weighing up the public safety concerns, we note that the Council is the organisation who is tasked with conducting investigations into product safety and that they concluded, after a full investigation, that no enforcement action was necessary.\n\n66.\n\nWe have also considered the Appellant’s submission that he sought information about the composition of the product because it was directly relevant to understanding the nature of the injury that he sustained and the risk to public safety. However, we note from the Council’s correspondence with the Commissioner that there are procedures in place outside of the FOIA process whereby a medical professional can contact Trading Standards for information about a product but that no such contact was ever made.\n\n67.\n\nThe Council has submitted that, even though the investigation into Company X was closed at the time of the request, the information may be used in any future investigation or enforcement action against the same company that may arise. Whilst we recognise that this is a possibility, we also note that the investigation closed in 2021 and that we have not seen evidence about any further complaints regarding the product in question. We have had regard to the Appellant’s submission that, if information was always said to have a speculative future potential use, it would effectively preclude any information from a closed investigation being disclosed. Whilst we do recognise that protecting any future proceedings is a factor in favour of maintaining the exemption, we only attach limited weight to it.\n\n68.\n\nHowever, the Tribunal accepts that a key consideration when determining the public interest balance in relation to the exemption under section 30 of the FOIA is whether disclosure could compromise the ability of the public authority to carry out its investigative work effectively. There is undoubtedly a strong public interest in enabling the Council to regulate and enforce compliance with the law. We therefore do place considerable weight on the Council’s submission that it is dependent on the voluntary cooperation of members of the public, and that undermining the willingness of companies or the public to engage with them and assist their enquiries is likely to impact on their ability to discharge their functions effectively. Whilst we do recognise that the Council has statutory powers of investigation and compulsion, we accept the assessment by the Council as to the significant importance of maintaining and encouraging voluntary cooperation and of protecting this key ‘tool’ in the investigatory arsenal. The Tribunal also bears in mind that disclosure of information to a direct competitor is precisely the type of situation which risks undermining the incentive for companies to cooperate on a voluntary basis.\n\n69.\n\nThe Appellant has submitted that the fact that the Council changed its position as to which limb of section 30(1) of the FOIA applied should have counted against a blanket refusal as it demonstrated that the refusal was not correctly framed from the outset. The Tribunal does not attach any weight to this submission – the issue for us to determine is whether the Commissioner has erred in law or should have applied his discretion differently. In addition, it is recognised that it is open for a public authority to raise a different exemption following an internal review or during the course of the Commissioner’s investigation.\n\n70.\n\nFor the reasons outlined above, and in particular the need to protect the ability of the Council to properly and effectively exercise their statutory functions, we are satisfied that the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosure of the requested material.\n\n71.\n\nThe Tribunal has considered whether partial, redacted or summarised disclosure would be appropriate in this case. In doing so, we have reviewed the material in the closed bundle and the information contained on the six test house certificates. Given the public interest factors that mitigate against disclosure outlined above, we are satisfied that partial, redacted or summarised disclosure would not be the correct approach in this matter.\n\n72.\n\nGiven that the Tribunal is satisfied that the exemption under section 30(1) of the FOIA is engaged and that the public interest is in favour of maintaining the exemption, we are not required to go on to consider the applicability of the exemption in section 43(2) of the FOIA. Notwithstanding that we have not formally considered it, the Tribunal is satisfied that, for the purposes of parts 1, 2, and 3 of the request, the exemption in section 43(2) of the FOIA would be engaged. We are also satisfied that the public interest in favour of protecting trade secrets and commercially-sensitive information would outweigh the public interest in disclosure.\n\nConclusion\n\n73.\n\nThe Tribunal is satisfied that the Commissioner was correct to conclude that exemption pursuant to section 30(1)(b) of the FOIA was engaged, and that the public authority were correct in determining that the public interest in favour of maintaining the exemption outweighed the public interest in disclosure of the information.\n\n74.\n\nThe Tribunal dismisses the appeal for the reasons given above.","changes":[]}