{"check":null,"uid":"9fd0fe5fd63be7c2","title":"HUNDRED ART AND CREATIVE LTD v. THAI RELAX LTD AND ANOTHER, [2026] HKCFI 5807, HCIP86/2025","title_generated":false,"country":"Гонконг","organ":"Судебная система Гонконга","kind":"case","kind_name":"Судебная практика","lang":"en","date":"2026-10-14","summary":"Суд рассмотрел дело о нарушении судебного запрета одним оператором связи другим оператором связи и физическим лицом о распространении объектов авторского права. Установлено, что ответчик нарушил запрет путем размещения новых материалов, схожих с объектами авторского права истца. Суд учел степень вины ответчиков, их признание нарушения и предпринятые ими действия по исправлению ситуации, назначив штраф и тюремное заключение под условием отсрочки исполнения. Решение подчеркивает важность соблюдения судебных предписаний и защиты авторских прав.","snippet":"","topics":["Интеллектуальная собственность в цифровой среде"],"status":"ok","error":"","text_len":15303,"versions":1,"url":"https://legalref.judiciary.hk/lrs/common/ju/ju_frame.jsp?DIS=186037&currpage=T","first_seen":"2026-10-16","last_checked":"2026-11-16 07:36","relevance":"hit","score":12,"query":"","source_key":"legalref_hk","verdict":{"relevance":"hit","score":12,"topics":["Интеллектуальная собственность в цифровой среде"],"need_body":3,"authorities":[],"evidence":[{"topic":"Интеллектуальная собственность в цифровой среде","term":"intellectual property","weak":true,"pos":197,"ctx":"the high court of the  hong kong special administrative region  court of first instance  intellectual property proceedings no 86 of 2025  _____________________  in the matter of high court intellectua","zone":"текст","weight":0},{"topic":"Интеллектуальная собственность в цифровой среде","term":"intellectual property","weak":true,"pos":297,"ctx":"al property proceedings no 86 of 2025  _____________________  in the matter of high court intellectual property case no 2 of 2025  and  in the matter of an application by hundred art and creative limit","zone":"текст","weight":0},{"topic":"Интеллектуальная собственность в цифровой среде","term":"copyright","weak":false,"pos":1380,"ctx":"n action under hcip 2/2025 (“ the action ”).  2. p commenced the action for his claim for copyright infringement in respect of its original literary and artistic works (“ p’s copyright work","zone":"текст","weight":1},{"topic":"Интеллектуальная собственность в цифровой среде","term":"copyright","weak":false,"pos":1465,"ctx":"for copyright infringement in respect of its original literary and artistic works (“ p’s copyright works ”) contained in its promotional materials for its thai massage service business in","zone":"текст","weight":1},{"topic":"Интеллектуальная собственность в цифровой среде","term":"copyright","weak":false,"pos":2243,"ctx":"r the trade name of “tora massage 白虎巡按” and it has a website to promote its business. p’s copyright works appears in the website.  6. on the other hand, d1 is a locally incorporated company","zone":"текст","weight":1},{"topic":"Интеллектуальная собственность в цифровой среде","term":"copyright","weak":false,"pos":2723,"ctx":"8. p discovered that the promotional material in the website was an infringement of its copyright in the copyright works (“ the old offensive works ”) in december 2024 and hence commenced","zone":"текст","weight":1}],"dropped":[]},"last_changed":"2026-10-16","meta":{"case_no":"HCIP86/2025","ncn":"[2026] HKCFI 5807","parties":"HUNDRED ART AND CREATIVE LTD v. THAI RELAX LTD AND ANOTHER","lang":"English","uploaded":"2026-10-15","organ":"Судебная система Гонконга"},"source_url":"https://legalref.judiciary.hk/lrs/common/ju/ju_frame.jsp?DIS=186037&currpage=T","text":"HCIP86/2025 HUNDRED ART AND CREATIVE LTD v. THAI RELAX LTD AND ANOTHER\n\nHCIP 86/2025\n\n[2026] HKCFI 5807\n\nIN THE HIGH COURT OF THE\n\nHONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION\n\nCOURT OF FIRST INSTANCE\n\nINTELLECTUAL PROPERTY PROCEEDINGS NO 86 OF 2025\n\n_____________________\n\nIN THE MATTER OF HIGH COURT INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY CASE NO 2 OF 2025\n\nAnd\n\nIN THE MATTER of an application by HUNDRED ART AND CREATIVE LIMITED for leave to apply for an\nOrder of Committal against THAI RELAX LIMITED and CHU PUI SHAN SHANNON 朱佩珊\n\nAnd\n\nIN THE MATTER of an application by HUNDRED ART AND CREATIVE LIMITED for leave to issue Writ of\nSequestration against THAI RELAX LIMITED and CHU PUI SHAN SHANNON 朱佩珊\n\n________________________\n\nBETWEEN\n\nHUNDRED ART AND CREATIVE LIMITED\n\nPlaintiff\n\nAND\n\nTHAI RELAX LIMITED\n\n1\nst\nDefendant\n\nPUI SHAN SHANNON CHU (朱佩珊)\n\n2\nnd\nDefendant\n\n________________________\n\nBefore:\n\nDeputy High Court Judge Kent Yee in Open Court\n\nDate of Hearing:\n\n14 October 2026\n\nDate of Judgment:\n\n14 October 2026\n\n_____________________\n\nJUDGMENT\n\n_____________________\n\nIntroduction\n\n1.\nBy an Originating Summons dated 8 December 2025 (“\nthe\nOS\n”), P instituted these committal proceedings which concern Ds’ breach of an injunction order made by\nHon S T Poon J dated 25 April 2025 (“\nthe Order\n”) in an action under HCIP 2/2025 (“\nthe Action\n”).\n\n2.\nP commenced the Action for his claim for copyright\ninfringement in respect of its original literary and artistic works (“\nP’s Copyright Works\n”) contained in\nits promotional materials for its Thai massage service business in Hong Kong. D1 carries on a similar business.\n\n3.\nThe substantive hearing of the OS was fixed for\n12 October 2026 with three days reserved. By their letters dated 16 September 2026, Ds indicated\ntheir admission of contempt. In light of this change of position, it was directed that the parties should\nfile relevant affirmations and written submissions for sentencing purposes and the hearing time should be\ncurtailed to one day.\n\n4.\nAt this hearing, Mr Wong appeared for P and Mr Tse appeared\nfor Ds.\n\nBackground facts\n\n5.\nAt all material times, P’s Thai massage business is carried\non under the trade name of “Tora Massage 白虎巡按” and it has a website to promote its business. P’s Copyright Works\nappears in the website.\n\n6.\nOn the other hand, D1 is a locally incorporated company\noperating its Thai massage business under the trade name of “自在。泰 Me Thai” with its website at\nhttp://www.methai.hk (“\nthe Website\n”).\n\n7.\nD2 was the sole shareholder and director of D1 until she sold\nher entire interest in D1 to one Mr Jiang and resigned from the office in September 2026.\n\n8.\nP discovered that the promotional material in the Website was\nan infringement of its copyright in the Copyright Works (“\nthe Old Offensive Works\n”) in December 2024 and\nhence commenced the Action by taking out the writ therein on 10 January 2025.\n\n9.\nBy an acknowledgement of service dated 23 January 2025, Ds\nindicated that they would contest quantum of damages only.\n\n10.\nOn 25 March 2025, P issued a summons pursuant to O.27 r.3\n(“\nthe Admission Summons\n”) for judgment on admission against Ds.\n\n11.\nS T Poon J heard the Admission Summons on 25 April 2025\nand made the Order, which contains the following terms:\n\n“1. The Defendants and each of them, in the case of the 1\nst\nDefendant, whether\nacting by itself, its directors, officers, servants, employees, agents or any of them or otherwise\nhowsoever, and in the case of the 2\nnd\nDefendants whether acting by herself, her business,\npartners, servants, agents, or any of them or otherwise howsoever, be restrained and a permanent injunction\nis hereby granted against the Defendants and each of them from infringing the Plaintiff’s copyright\nsubsisting in the Copyright Works as defined in paragraph 6 of the Statement of Claim filed on\n18\nth\nFebruary 2025 (\"Statement of Claim\") and from directing, procuring, instigating, causing,\nenabling or assisting others in committing any of the aforesaid acts.\n\n2. Without prejudice to the generality of Paragraph 1 above, the 1\nst\nDefendant\nwhether acting by itself, its directors, officers, servants, employees or agents or any of them or otherwise\nhowsoever, and in the case of the 2\nnd\nDefendant, whether acting by herself, her business,\npartners, servants, agents or any of them otherwise howsoever be restrained and a permanent injunction is\ngranted against each of the 1\nst\nand 2\nnd\nDefendants without the consent of the\nPlaintiff, reproducing, using, issuing to the public, making available to the public, distributing,\nsupplying and/ or otherwise dealing in or with the Infringing Materials as defined in paragraph 9 of the\nStatement of Claim.”\n\n12.\nIn or about September 2025, P discovered that new\ninfringing materials (“\nthe New Offensive Works\n”) appear in the Website.\n\n13.\nOn 24 October 2025, P applied for leave to institute\ncontempt proceedings against Ds with a Statement pursuant to O.52 r.2 (“\nthe Statement\n”) filed on the same\nday.\n\n14.\nHon Lok J granted leave to P on 24 November 2025 and hence\nthe OS was taken out on 8 December 2025.\n\n15.\nDs removed the New Offensive Works from the Website on or\nabout 23 December 2025.\n\n16.\nOn the admission of Ds, I find that the allegations in the\nStatement and, thus, the contempt are proved.\n\nThe Breach and Ds’ explanation\n\n17.\nDs admit the breach of the Order by publishing the New\nOffensive Works at the Website from May to December 2025.\n\n18.\nMr Wong submits that the New Offensive Works bear an\noverall 92.8% resemblance to the Old Offensive Works and they are 91.5% similar to the Copyright Works. Mr\nTse does not demur.\n\n19.\nD2 has proffered an explanation for the breach in her\n2\nnd\nAffirmation and it is summarised by Mr Tse as follows:\n\n(a) D2 left matters concerning the Website to her husband’s elder brother Mr Chim whom she trusted\nand relied on completely.\n\n(b) After being served with the Statement of Claim in the Action in February 2025, she\nspecifically instructed Mr Chim that the new content must not reproduce or copy the materials in the Old\nOffensive Works and must be materially different from the Copyright Works. She also told Mr Chim that\nthe Website must not be made available to the public until she had reviewed it to which Mr Chim said he\nunderstood.\n\n(c) From February 2025 onwards, D2 left the redevelopment of the Website entirely to Mr Chim, on\nthe footing that nothing would be published until she had approved it. As nothing had been brought to\nMs Chu for approval, she assumed that nothing had been published and that Mr Chim was still redeveloping the\nWebsite.\n\n(d) After being served with the Order on 28 May 2025, D2 reminded Mr Chim again that the Website\nafter redevelopment must not reproduce or copy the materials in the Old Offensive Works. However, Mr Chim\ndid not tell Ms Chu that the Website had already been published and she does not know why Mr Chim did\nnot tell her at the time.\n\n(e) She only first learned of the New Offensive Works when she was served with the papers in these\nproceedings on 23 December 2025. She immediately contacted Mr Chim and he apologised and informed her\nthat he had used an AI tool called “POE” to assist in rewriting the contents for the new website and\n(erroneously) concluded that it was sufficiently different from the Copyright Works.\n\n(f) The Website has since been taken down and remains inaccessible to the public.\n\nApplicable sentencing principles\n\n20.\nBoth Mr Wong and Mr Tse refer to the often-cited decision\nof Au Yeung J in\nArboit v Koo Siu Ying (No.2)\n[2016] 3 HKLRD 154 in which the learned judge set out the\ngeneral principles of sentencing in contempt proceedings as follows (with citation of authorities omitted):\n\n“2. The starting point is to acknowledge that contempt of civil court orders is a serious\nmatter and that court orders are made to be obeyed. A prime consideration of the court in sentencing\ncontempt is to “signal importance of demonstrating to litigants that the orders of these courts are to be\nobeyed”. By “litigants”, it is clearly referring to litigants in general and not just the contemnor himself…\n\n3. The object of the sentence is both to punish conduct in defiance of the court’s order and to\nserve a coercive function by holding out the threat of future punishment as a means of securing the\nprotection which the order was primarily there to do…\n\n4. The sentence for contempt may range from a fine to a term of imprisonment. The UK Contempt\nof Court Act 1981 imposes a maximum term of 2 years’ imprisonment but Hong Kong does not have that statutory\nlimit…\n\n5. Imprisonment should be regarded as a sanction of the last resort. Any custodial sentence\nshould be as short as possible consistent with the circumstances of the case…\n\n6. The court may suspend a term of imprisonment for such period or on such terms as the court\ndeems fit [under O.52 r.7 of the Rules of the High Court. This is an “absolute discretion” but it would be\ndifficult to think of circumstances where a suspended order should be made when nothing further remains to\nbe done to comply with the order…\n\n7. The court will consider if there are:\n\n(a) Aggravating factors;\n\n(b) Mitigating Factors; and\n\n(c) Acts to purge the contempt, ie acts to atone for a contempt, eradicate it or cleanse it\nof\nits previous ill-effect which, in the case of a mandatory order, may be fulfilled if the contemnor\nthereupon\ndoes the act or causes it to be done.\n\n8. Relevant factors (which are not exhaustive) include:\n\n(a) The nature of the order and breach in question, and the extent of the breach;\n\n(b) Whether the contempt was contumacious or unintentional, the reasons, motives and state\nof\nmind;\n\n(c) Whether the claimant has been prejudiced by virtue of the contempt and whether the\nprejudice is capable of remedy;\n\n(d) Whether the contemnor appreciates the seriousness of the deliberate breach;\n\n(e) Whether the contemnor has cooperated.\n\n21.\nMr Tse further draws my attention to\nSolar System\nInternational Company Ltd v Unison-Watch Manufacturing Ltd & Wong Chung Kan\n(unreported,\nCACV3523/2001, 7.2.2002) in which Rogers VP held (at §24) that once the court has reached the conclusion that a\ncontempt was not deliberate or not contemptuous, it would be in very rare circumstances that a sentence of\nimprisonment would be appropriate.\n\nAnalysis\n\n22.\nMr Wong submits that the explanation given by D2 is\ndubious and is not supported by any corroborative evidence of Mr Chim. He also highlights that D2 was not\nvery frank with her relationship with Mr Chim and it was only disclosed subsequently that Mr Chim was her\nbrother-in-law. Mr Wong submits that even if this court accepts her explanation, the breach was\ncontemptuous and a sentence of imprisonment is still appropriate.\n\n23.\nMr Wong further submits that the apology made by D2 in her\n2\nnd\nAffirmation was late and her remorse was not genuine.\n\n24.\nThat said, Mr Wong fairly accepts that the purge of the\ncontempt albeit late remains a strong mitigating factor.\n\n25.\nMr Tse places heavy emphasis on the purge of the contempt\nand the genuine remorse displayed by D2 in her full and unreserved apology to both this court and P in her\n2\nnd\nAffirmation (“\nthe Apology\n”). He goes on to say that there is no realistic risk of further\nbreach of the Order given D2’s departure from D1. Lastly, Mr Tse submits that any prejudice caused to P by the\npublication of the New Offensive Works can be remediable financially.\n\n26.\nIn sentencing, I take into account the following matters\nin addition to the submissions of counsel.\n\n27.\nRight from the outset, Ds admitted their infringement of\nP’s copyright in the Copyright Works and their admission led to the making of the Order only 4 months after the\nAction was commenced.\n\n28.\nShortly after being served the Order, the Old Offensive\nWorks were replaced by the New Offensive Works. This shows that Ds did take a step to comply with the Order.\nWhether the step was enough is another matter.\n\n29.\nI am inclined to accept D2’s account that she had\ndelegated to Mr Chim the task of complying with the Order. Mr Chim failed miserably to carry out the\ninstructions with the New Offensive Works, however.\n\n30.\nWhether Mr Chim himself personally committed a contempt is\nbeside the point.\n\n31.\nIt is unreasonable for Ds to rely on Mr Chim entirely\nwithout themselves checking whether the Website, contrary to the report of Mr Chim, was still in operation and\ncontinued to contain any offensive works in breach of the Order. The Order is made against them and Ds must be\nalarmed and should have made an all-out effort to avoid any non-compliance. Ds have been legally represented\nthroughout and they should be aware of the serious consequences that would follow if they are in breach of the\nOrder. They needed not spend much time and effort to find out whether the Website still contained anything which\nmight constitute a breach of the Order.\n\n32.\nI do not accept that Ds intentionally breached the Order.\nI accept that D2 fully relied on Mr Chim to comply with the Order though she should not have done so. However\nunwise Ds were, I do not think that Ds breached the order contemptuously.\n\n33.\nDs’ purge was made in a timeously manner. This is indeed a\nstrong mitigating factor.\n\n34.\nI further accept that the Apology was\nbona fide\nand\nshows the genuine remorse of Ds.\n\n35.\nDs’ admission of contempt, though could have been made\nearlier, further shows their remorse. It has saved considerable judicial resources.\n\n36.\nMr Wong is right in his submission that in intellectual\nproperty actions, injunctions are of paramount importance for the protection of the plaintiffs’ interests. Ds’\nbreach of the Order is a deprivation of an important protection afforded to P and it must be a serious matter.\n\n37.\nI do not accept the submission of Mr Tse that an indemnity\ncosts order is already a heavy penalty to D2. Whilst D2 is likely to be hit hard financially if she is ordered\nto pay indemnity costs to P, such a costs order is only compensatory and not punitive in nature. These contempt\nproceedings were necessitated wholly by their breach of the Order and there is no reason why Ds should not fully\ncompensate P for their legal costs.\n\n38.\nFor D1, I believe that a substantial fine could adequately\nreflect its culpability. There is no credible evidence of the current financial condition of D1 and the\nunaudited balance sheet shows that it is in the red. I order that D1 should pay a fine of HK$100,000 within 28\ndays from the date of this order.\n\n39.\nD2 is very close to the prison gate given the gravity of\nthe breach. Nevertheless, I believe that the mitigating factors identified above can justify a suspension of the\nimprisonment term pursuant to O.52 r.7. I order that D2 shall be sentenced to 14 days’ imprisonment to be\nsuspended for 12 months.\n\n40.\nDs sensibly agree to pay indemnity costs to P.\nAccordingly, I order that costs of and occasioned by the OS including all costs reserved be paid by Ds to P on\nan indemnity basis, to be taxed if not agreed.\n\n41.\nLastly, I thank Mr Wong and Mr Tse for their helpful\nassistance.\n\n(Kent Yee)\nDeputy High Court Judge\n\nMr Philips B F Wong, instructed by Messrs Benny Kong & Tsai, for the Plaintiff\n\nMr William Tse, instructed by Messrs Yung, Yu, Yuen & Co, for the 1\nst\nand\n2\nnd\nDefendants","changes":[]}